Skip to main content

Full text of "Clinical lectures on amblyopia and amaurosis"

See other formats


v Professor A. von GRAEFE, 


EXTRACTION of cataract. 

Eranslateo from tfje ffiettnan 

Surgeon to the Massachusetts Charitable Eye and Ear Infirmary ; Member of the Heidelberg 

Ophthalmologische Gesellschaft ; Member of the American Ophthalmological 

Society, &c. &c. 











Professor A. von GRAEFE, 





SranslateU from tfje dSctxmm 

Stffgeon to the Massachusetts Charitable Eye and Ear Infirmary ; Member of the Heidelberg 

Ophthalmologische Gesellscbaft ; Member of the American Ophthalmological 

Society, &c. &c. 





This translation was made during the past winter for the Boston 
Medical and Surgical Journal, and is now collected from its pages. 
Its publication is undertaken for the two-fold object of introducing 
Albrecht von Graefe to the American medical public as a clinical 
teacher, and of exhibiting the progress which has been made in the 
exploration of one of the most obscure departments of ophthalmic 
science, and for which we are indebted to his genius and industry. 

In his first work on Astigmatism, published in 1862, Donders 
relates a case of Myopia, complicated seemingly with an amount of 
Amblyopia too great to be accounted for by the moderate near-sight- 
edness. Local depletion and other treatment w6*rked no change- 
Three years later, thanks to the progress of science in the interval; 
the difficulty was found to be dependent on Astigmatism, and was 
relieved by appropriate glasses. The illustrious professor thus com 
ments on the case. "This instance is one of thousands where 
Astigmatism has been confounded with and treated as Amblyopia. 
The tortures the patient suffered from the severe and futile treatment 
were compensated for by the indescribable joy he experienced in find- 
ing his vision improved for every distance by appropriate glasses j" and 
in another place he says, " this discovery goes another step to contract 
the domain of as yet unexplained Amblyopia." Efforts for its relief 
were however not to stop here. The work has been pushed on with 
equal ardor by von Graefe, and those who have the patience to mas- 
ter his close and minute reasoning will find many difficulties that had 


previously beset their path in the treatment of these affections, ex- 
plained and cleared away. 

With reference to the series of clinical remarks on the extraction 
of cataract which form the conclusion of this pamphlet, and which, 
as a specimen of clear, precise and comprehensive clinical instruc- 
tion, the translator believes to be without a parallel in ophthalmic 
literature, it may be well to remark that their value is in no wise 
diminished by the late researches of von Graefe on modified linear 
extraction and his present frequent adoption of the method. Till 
vastly more extended statistics have proved the superior safety of 
another procedure, flap extraction must remain the rule in a large 
proportion of cases and for the majority of practitioners. 

The lectures on Amblyopia and Amaurosis were compiled and 
reported by Dr. Engelhardt, and were translated from the Klinische 
Monatsblatter fur Augenheilkunde for 1865. Those on the extrac- 
tion of cataract were taken from the volume of the same magazine 
for 1863. 

6 Beacon Street, Boston, 
May 25, 1866. 


In cases of Amblyopia,* three things aid us in general in arriving 
at our conclusions. First, the functional state of the eye, carefully 
considered ; second, the appearance of the papilla ; third, the manner 
in which the affection has become developed. 

As regards the functional derangements, it is not to be denied 
that the amount of impairment of central vision is of great impor- 
tance ; although the prognosis as regards possible blindness would 
depend yet more on an accurate investigation of the limits of the 
field of vision and of eccentric sight. Experience has abundantly 
shown those forms which tend to progressive blindness to be charac- 
terized by an early narrowing of the field of vision, a preponderat- 
ing loss of sensibility of the peripheric portions of the retina. It is, 
a priori, readily imaginable that, in a progressing atrophy of the 
nervous elements, those regions should first suffer which are most 
remote from the nutritive and functional centre, and that thus the 
extinction of power should be successive and, to a certain extent, 

Inasmuch, therefore, as extreme significance is to be attached to a 
defective or diminished peripheric vision, our methods of diagnosti- 
cating the same must be as perfect as possible. Ordinary daylight 
is insufficient to detect slight defects in making a general examina- 
tion of the periphery of the field of vision. This must rather be 
conducted in a darkened room where light proceeds from but a sin- 
gle source. Where absolute accuracy is desirable, the " graduated 
lamp "f may be used: the diaphragm being set at 100, and a black 

* From this class we of course exclude all those affections which proceed from visible 
changes in the refractive media, or in the internal structure of the eye ; as also cases of 
neuroretinitis and embolia. 

f A lamp so arranged as to diffuse a greater or less amount of light, according to the size 
of the opening in the movable diaphragm which is placed before it.— Translator. 


paper without gloss being held before the patient (of course at a 
fixed distance). The limits of the field of vision are ascertained by 
means of white balls, set on a black rod and gradually removed 
from the point of fixation. To ascertain the angle of distinction in 
eccentric vision, the balls may be placed on the two extremities of a 
blackened pair of compasses. 

The results of this, or a similar examination of the limits of the 
field of vision may be set down under three heads : — 

1. Peripheric vision is relatively the same as in a sound eye. 

2. Peripheric vision has suffered a diminution, equal, however, in 
every direction, and relatively of slighter amount than the derange- 
ment of central vision. 

3. The derangement of eccentric vision is unequal, i. e., most 
marked in one direction, or in certain directions ; extends from the 
edge over the surface of the field of vision, and plays no longer a 
subordinate role in comparison with the derangement of central 

In the first case we designate the limits of the field of vision as 
absolutely normal, in the second as relatively normal, in the third as 
abnormal. In considering cases by themselves, we will enter into a 
more detailed explanation of these distinctions. 

Where the limits of the field of vision are absolutely normal (1), 
progressive atrophy, i. e., actual amaurosis, need never be suspected 
provided only that the affection has in other respects properly de- 
clared itself. I do not undertake to deny that there is an initial 
stage where clearly defined symptoms may not yet have become de- 
veloped, and it is well to avoid giving a decided opinion in a case of 
recent and imperfectly developed amblyopia. Suppose an instance 
where, within a few weeks, the acuteness of vision has fallen only to §, 
and the limits of the field of vision are absolutely normal, we are 
still in no condition to give a positive opinion for the possibility of 
a further diminution of the acuteness of vision, and ultimate en- 
croachments on the periphery of the field of vision is by no means 
excluded. Has, on the other hand, an affection existed several 
months, and does the periphery of the field of vision remain abso- 
lutely normal, even though the marked diminution of the acuteness 
of vision to £, T V, or even less, shows the settled nature of the dif- 
ficulty, we may safely conclude that the process is not one of pro- 
gressive atrophy (amaurosis). And thus it may be seen that we 

are unable to approach a comparatively light case without some de* 
gree of apprehension, and yet may give a favorable opinion in an 
apparently graver condition of things. In speaking, however, here 
of a favorable prognosis, I wish to be understood as referring only 
to the approach of amaurosis, and not of an entire recovery. We 
meet a variety of amblyopic conditions, where the periphery of the 
field of vision is intact, but where central or eccentric scotomas ex- 
ist, which baffle all treatment and, after reaching a certain height or 
diminishing within certain bounds, remain permanent. Of this, more 

If the field of vision is relatively normal (2), i. e., if an equal loss 
has taken place in all portions of the periphery, slight in compari- 
son with the derangement of central vision, the affair is a dubious one.. 
We may get information from a simultaneous glance at the optic nerve, 
the age and the manner in which the disease has developed itself, 
but not from the functional derangements alone. Considered by it- 
self, this form is by no means a serious one, being the same that 
occurs in loss of retinal sensibility ; for example, in long-continued 
cases of loss of vision of one eye, and may be artificially produced 
by bringing a piece of deeply smoked glass before the eye. Just, 
then, as eyes excluded from the act of common vision by a cause 
still in force — strabismus, for example — may have eccentric vision 
outwards predominate over that inwards, and finally over the cen- 
tral, and may thus become progressively amaurotic, so we see, in the 
case of amblyopic eyes with a relatively normal field of vision, the 
cause of the disease still existing (as in the case of drunkards), that 
progressive atrophy may result. On the other hand, we may witness 
complete restitution, as in anopsia. In fact, where the field of vision 
is still relatively normal, we are not dealing with a characteristic 
case of progressive atrophy. A rational and discriminating system 
of treatment is here specially called for. 

And, finally, if the limits of the field of vision be abnormal (3), the 
case assumes a more threatening aspect ; though it would be going 
much too far to regard all belonging to this class as necessarily tending 
to a fatal termination. We have to first take into account the manner 
in which the field of vision is contracted, next to compare this with the 
acuteness of vision in the centre of the field ; thirdly, to regard the 
appearance of the papilla ; fourthly, the manner of development of 
the disease. The last two points will be considered in another con- 
nection. The following remarks pertain to the first two. 

If the limitation of the field of vision be on one and the same 
side of the body, for example on the right (or right and downwards, 
right and upwards), and if central vision is normal, or nearly so, 
then only one tractus opticus is affected. The disease, as such, may 
end in complete hemiopia on corresponding sides, never, however, in 
blindness (Case IV.). An extremely exceptional state of things (and 
one that admits as yet of no anatomical explanation) is the finding 
of limitations in the field upwards or downwards, on one or both 
sides, in the last event symmetrical, which, when they occur separa- 
ted by a sharply-defined boundary from that portion of the field 
retaining its normal functions, and when vision is of normal acute- 
ness, give no reason for suspecting progressive atrophy. Actual 
concentric narrowing of the field of vision sometimes may be ob- 
served to result in blindness, the field growing gradually smaller? 
but preserving its form (as in exceptional cases of glaucoma), al- 
though such a state of things seems in general to depend on causes 
which may be arrested in their operation and even removed. The 
latter may with some confidence be looked for when the papilla has 
preserved a normal appearance, when the acuteness of vision has 
become only moderately impaired, and when by the use of dark blue 
glasses (shade No. 6 to No. 8) a partial increase of peripheric vision 
may be effected (as in hysterical anaesthesia of the retina and a pe- 
culiar form met with in nervous children). The most unfavora- 
ble cases are those where an irregular "lateral contraction of the 
field of vision has taken place, attacking the two eyes either simul- 
taneously or successively, and after such a fashion that the periphery 
of the field of vision becomes principally impaired inwards or out- 
wards (or in an intermediate direction, outwards and downwards? 
inwards and upwards, &c); I say principally impaired, for besides 
the marked contraction on one side there is generally a lack of dis- 
tinct perception in other directions. The principal distinction be- 
tween these limitations and those described in hemiopia consists in 
the fact that the portion whose function has become impaired is 
never separated by a sharply-defined line of demarcation from a 
part retaining its normal functions, but that a gradual transition 
takes place through a tract the activity of which grows greater to- 
wards the centre and less towards the periphery. The graver forms 
of amaurosis generally run such a course as to have seriously affected 
the first eye, having caused, for example, the contraction of the field 
of vision to have already passed the point of fixation, when the 


second eye begins to be involved (see below). In order to be 
assured of the soundness of the second eye, its field of vision must 
be closely scanned in that quarter where ominous symptoms are 
most to be feared. Was the first eye first invaded by a cutting 
off of the field of vision downwards and inwards, the periphery of 
that of the second eye must be carefully watched in the same region, 
and so must the temporal border if the temporal side of the other 
eye was first affected. These observations are all the more essen- 
tial because, why we know not, an interval of several or even of 
many years often elapses between the affection of the two sides, 
while, on the other hand, one may follow on the heels of the other. 
It most frequently happens in amaurosis that the first derangement 
occurs on the nasal border of the field of vision, and that the tem- 
poral half holds out the longest. This may be owing to the ana- 
tomical arrangement of the optic-nerve expansion and to its physio- 
logical consequences, inasmuch as that lateral portion of the field of 
vision which belongs to each eye for itself is furnished exclusively 
by the distribution of the fibres on the nasal side. Although, indeed, 
in processes involving atrophy, so many cases occur where an ex- 
actly opposite condition of things is found, viz., the occurrence of 
the first derangement in the temporal half of the field of vision, 
that we cannot, as in glaucoma, name them exceptions to a general 
rule, but must rather look upon them as in the minority. Should it 
happen that the second eye should not become affected on the same 
side (medial or temporal), but rather on the opposite, i. e., the side 
corresponding with that side of the body, the case might, as in the for- 
mer instance, be one involving only one tractus opticus, developing 
itself successively in the fasciculus lateralis and cruciatus, and threat- 
ening consequently not blindness, but only hemiopia on correspond- 
ing sides j in this hope, however, we only dare indulge when, 1st, 
the limitation of the field of vision on the first eye does not cross 
the vertical line of separation passing through the point of fixation ; 
2d, when the acuteness of vision has not materially diminished, per. 
haps not below £ or |. If the case be otherwise, this mode of de- 
velopment, relatively infrequent though it be, must excite the suspi- 
cion of approaching atrophy. 

Is the survey of the periphery of the field of vision of the first 
importance as regards progressive atrophy, so, on the other hand, 
may we deduce from a knowledge of its continuity very important 


inferences as regards the question of recovery. It may be generally 
laid down that those cases of amblyopia in which the continuity of 
the field is nearest its normal state, offer the best chance of recove- 
ry (Case I.). Accordingly if, with a diminution of the acuteness of 
vision, we find the eccentric acuteness correspondingly affected, so 
that, in accordance with the common law, it gradually diminishes to- 
wards the periphery and does not in certain spots undergo interrup- 
tions or sudden diminutions, we are at liberty to form a more favora- 
ble prognosis than if central acuteness of vision had been impaired 
over a defined spot, sharply separated from the surrounding parts 
(central blur, central scotoma, central defect), or if a slight impair- 
ment of acuteness of vision were accompanied by eccentric inter- 
ruptions. Causes of disease seem often to be at work, in the case 
of central or eccentric scotoma, which lead to a permanent impair- 
ment of sensitiveness. We often witness, at any rate, the persist- 
ence of such a state of things, and are therefore in a situation to 
give a prognosis only favorable as regards blindness, doubtful as re* 
gards ultimate recovery (Case III.). In such cases the state of the pa- 
pilla and the course of the disease afford us more tangible information. 
I again insist on the fact that, in order to give a favorable prognosis 
as regards blindness in cases of central and eccentric scotoma, we 
must have a satisfactory amount of eccentric vision beyond the sco- 
toma, especially towards the periphery of the field. But if the case 
be one of scotoma, beyond which and in certain directions, even to 
the periphery of the field, the eccentric vision has become impaired, 
we have generally to do with a form of progressive atrophy (Case 
Y.). So, too, must we earefully investigate cases of eccentric scoto- 
ma, occupying corresponding places in the field of vision, for exam- 
ple, on each side the lower part. If the eccentric vision in the 
neighborhood of the scotoma, in the last-cited case below, is entirely 
normal, blindness is not to be feared, indeed the capacity of the 
layer of fibres corresponding to the scotoma must be normal. If 
the case be otherwise, such a derangement is not infrequently the 
precursor of an amaurotic affection. 

Beside the diminution of central and eccentric acuteness of vision, many other 
features of amblyopic affections have had more or less importance attached to 
them as influencing the prognosis. This was particularly the case before the in- 
vention of the ophthalmoscope, when it was impossible to accurately distinguish 
amblyopia, in the present sense of the word, from affections of the internal 
structures, from inflammations of the optic nerve, and even in part from impair- 


ments in the transparency of the refractive media. Since the classification has 
been completed, the worthlessness of most of these symptoms has become mani- 
fest. Let me briefly refer to some of them. The subjective appearances of light* 
both plain and colored, as also in the form of subjective pictures, occur to any 
extent in comparatively few amblyopic cases, and, when present, give more infor- 
mation as to the accompanying condition of the brain itself (as in encephalitis, 
delirium tremens) than as to the state of the amblyopia. Vastly more importance 
is to be attached to these phenomena in diseases of the deep-seated membranes, 
as they here not only sometimes indicate the duration of the progressive periods, 
but are even of importance as prodromal symptoms (as, for example, in cases of 
separation of the retina, where they may occur as white balls, drops, or in crescentic 
shapes, which I attribute to the tension near the equator). The weight laid on 
these symptoms formerly in cases of amaurosis is due in great measure to the 
fact that these cases were confounded with affections of the deeper structures. 
Again, these appearances may be present in their most intense form in an affec- 
tion, which (so far as it occurs idiopathically, involving neither the field nor the 
acuteness of vision) may be of some significance as relating to the cerebral eco- 
nomy, but never passes into amaurosis ; I mean the so-called hyperesthesia reti- 
nae. In cases of genuine amblyopia, misty or smoky vision is most intimately 
connected with a diminution of the central or eccentric acuteness of vision, and 
often only the direct indication of this on the part of the retina. 

It is at this <}ay hardly necessary to state that the pronounced mouches volantes 
we often meet in normal eyes (myoclesopsia) are in no wise indicative of amauro- 
sis. Their cause is partly optical, alterations of the state of refraction, of the 
range of accommodation, irregularities in the refractive media all facilitating the 
production of entoptical shadows of diffraction, partly depends on hyperesthesia 
of the retina, where shadows ordinarily invisible are brought out by the atten- 
tion concentrated on them. 

The favorable influence of convex glasses in amblyopia, as facilitating the re- 
cognition and survey of letters, has been used to aid the prognosis. This expe- 
riment, leaving out of account any mere correction of refraction, may be used in 
some cases to demonstrate the continuance of the acuteness of vision, and the full 
activity of the retina at its centre, gives us, however, in the end, no results that 
we could not have obtained from the examination of the central and eccentrio 

The old division of amaurosis into active and passive has practically passed 
away ; although it is not to be denied that in different forms, the relations of the 
acuteness and field of vision being apparently the same, the capacity of percep- 
tion is very differently affected by the amount of illumination, and that in this 
sense we may be said to be dealing with active and passive forms. It is well 
known that, in the case of a normal eye, the amount of illumination may vary 
within tolerably wide bounds ; for example, from bright daylight to much less, 
without exerting a perceptible influence on the acuteness of central or eccentric 
vision. It first becomes felt (in accordance with a yet undiscovered law) when 
the amount of illumination is reduced within certain bounds— for example, ap- 
proaches twilight. In the case of amblyopic eyes we find considerable fluctua- 
tions often produced by slight changes in the amount of natural, and generally 
by greater variations in the amount of artificial light. Where a decided dimimu 


tion is thus observed, we are justified in speaking of torpor of the retina in con- 
nection with the other circumstances of the case. Taking into account the preva- 
lent amount of central and eccentric vision, this "torpor" consists in an abnor- 
mally rapid diminution of each (or particularly of eccentric vision), the amount 
of illumination being diminished. On the other hand, cases are to be met with 
where perception is not diminished, or is even increased by a withdrawal of illu- 
mination that normal eyes would sensibly feel.* In these rare cases we find that 
in the twilight or while looking through deep-blue glasses distinctness of vision 
increases, and we may therefore contrast them as active forms with the more 
strongly-marked passive, and this all the more because, other things being equal, 
the prognosis is better. 

Color-blindness ; a not infrequent accompaniment of amblyopic affections, has 
been recently carefully investigated by Benedict, and especially by Schelske. 
That it is of any nosological use is, up to the present time, neither possible nor 
probable, inasmuch as Benedict declares that the pathological color-blindness may 
give way without any special alteration in the power of perception. 

Some, following in the footsteps of Serres d'Uzes, would find a thorough means 
of diagnosis in the examination of the phosphenes produced by pressure. This 
method is, however, here even less admissible than in cataracta complicata and 
closure of the pupil, inasmuch as in the unimpeded open determination of the 
powers of vision we possess a method at once more delicate, better calculated to 
directly ascertain the true nature of the disease, and more easy to 45arry into exe- 
cution. Only in rare cases of peripheric anaesthesia (as, for example, where con- 
centric narrowing of the field of vision occurs in connection with a sudden failure 
of cutaneous sensibility) are we forced to the interesting conclusion that 
phosphenes may be produced by pressing against portions of the retina that are 
insensible to light. In my opinion the solution is to be found in a loss of con- 
nection between the layer of rods and the nerve-fibres, and in such a case we may 
look upon the existence of the phosphene, taken in connection with other circum- 
stances, as rendering the prognosis more favorable. 

Finally, an attempt has been made to levy, for diagnostic and prognostic pur- 
poses, on the results of galvanic stimulation, and Bemak has recently published some 
communications of much interest, the continuation of which we must await, on 
the different reactions with regard to colors of the centre of the optic nerve in 
various cases of amblyopia. 

We turn now to the second head, namely, the condition of the 
optic-nerve entrance. We are indebted to the ophthalmoscope for 
having not only set defined bounds to the class of amblyopic affec- 

* In order to be exact in these statements many details must be added, and above all the 
intensity (I.) of illumination which is to be placed at the head of the scale of gradually de- 
creasing amounts of light. If a large amount of I. is taken, as much, for example, as 
would be represented by intense daylight, many amblyopic eyes possessing but confused 
vision would, as this intensity is decreased, at first seem to lose no distinctness of perception 
and only show signs of " torpor " after still further diminution. The remarks in the text 
above refer to that decrease in central and eccentric vision which follows when we descend 
the scale from ordinary daylight to that amount of I. which was recommended to be em- 
ployed in the more delicate examinations of the field of vision. 


tions by the exclusion of other intra-ocular diseases, but also for 
having discovered in the state of the optic papilla diagnostic marks 
of much importance in separate cases. Our attention is to be paid 
to four characteristic points, closely connected together and partially 
dependent the one on the other, viz. (a), alteration in color ; (b), opa- 
city ; (c), excavation ; and (d) diminution of the calibre of the vessels. 

While the intra-ocular end of the normal optic nerve, let its whole 
effect be white or yellow, still offers a well-marked reddish tint, 
which only partially gives way to the more decided bluish-white re- 
flex of the lamina cribrosa, as in the case perhaps of an existing 
physiological excavation ; in many cases of amblyopia, particularly 
the more serious, the whole face of the papilla becomes of an in- 
tense white. The contrast of color with the adjacent choroid be- 
comes naturally more marked, the edge of the latter appearing to 
have acquired an increased distinctness. This reflex occurs for a 
double reason — partly because the atrophy of the papilla lays bare 
more of the lamina cribrosa, which offers a stronger reflection ; part- 
ly because— -besides the disappearance of the nerve-fibres — a thick- 
ening of the connective-tissue elements takes place in the papillary 
section of the nerve. These two causes may be concerned together 
or separately in the change of color. If the first alone acts, the 
color becomes a bluish-white, and an excavation caused by atrophy 
results ; if the second acts, the consequence is an intense and pure 
whiteness of the papilla, the surface of which is smooth ; if both 
are concerned, the papilla becomes slightly excavated, the lamina 
cribrosa only visible in detail in places, perhaps through a preexisting 
physiological excavation, the remainder being concealed by a layer 
of white connective-tissue. The reason why sometimes one form 
and sometimes the other occurs, does not appear to lie in an essen- 
tial difference in the process of atrophy, but rather, as Schweigger's 
researches tend to show, in a preexisting variety in the form of the 
papilla and in the different physiological intra-ocular pressure, as 
also in the intermediate effects of a stimulated circulation (on 
the connective-tissue). The second criterion, the opacity, need hard- 
ly be referred to after what has been said. The delicate semi-trans- 
parency of the normal papilla is naturally wanting when the con- 
nective tissue of the lamina cribrosa, or the thickened tissue substi- 
tuted" at the extremity of the nerve, forms the visible boundary. We 
can no longer, as usual, see the trunks of the vessels dip in ; 


and are involuntarily impressed with the dead look of the 
opaque substance of the papilla in comparison with its usual 
appearance of vitality. The third criterion, the excavation, has 
also been sufficiently dwelt upon. As has been said, its presence 
or absence depends on the more negative or positive condi- 
tion of the inter-connective tissue in the atrophied extremity of the 
nerve. A few words, in conclusion, on the lessened size of the vessels. 
It is true that we sometimes find all the vessels, including the main 
trunks, diminished in calibre, but this is a rule that by no means in- 
variably applies to the latter. We may have a case of complete 
amaurosis of long standing, in which the optic nerve exhibits 
every sign of (nervous) atrophy, and where the main vessels 
have retained their normal diameter. A wholly different state 
of things obtains when atrophy of the optic nerve is the ulti- 
mate result of intra-ocular processes, for example of choroido-retini- 
tis ; in such a case the very diminution in size of the main vessels 
is the most regular and often most striking symptom. The ground 
of this diversity may be found in the fact that in cases of amauro- 
sis, so far as pathological investigations have yet reached, as also 
after the division of the optic nerve (Rosow), only the nerve-fibre 
and ganglion-cell layers atrophy, the rest of the retina maintaining 
itself; whereas, in cases of choroido-retinitis leading to disappearance 
of the optic entrance, the reverse is the case, the whole tissue of the 
retina becoming destroyed. The differences we notice in the calibre 
of the main vessels in cases of atrophic amaurosis may well (as in 
the case of the papilla) have their origin in the varying condition of 
the connective elements of the retina. The diminution in size, if 
not the complete disappearance of the smaller vascular ramifications 
on the papilla is, on the other hand, a constant symptom. The nor- 
mal red shade of the latter depends undoubtedly on the very large 
number of small vessels interwoven with it, and the absence of 
these vessels contributes very much to the whiteness found in cases 
of atrophy. It seems as though these fine branches ramifying on 
the papilla itself were almost exclusively destined to supply the in- 
tra-ocular extremity of the nerve and the fibres expanding in its 
vicinity, and it would be precisely these ramifications which would 
be most affected by the disappearance of the fibrous layer • while 
the largest portion of the bloodvessels of the retina would be pre- 
served for the supply of its other layers. The pallor of the papilla 


caused by the diminished size of these ramifications has, of course, 
an appreciable effect on the change of color. If the semi-transpa- 
rence be tolerably well preserved it may precede other symp- 
toms and be indicative of the first period of the affection, during 
which an ordinary examination of the field of vision discovers no 
anomaly ; and it needs the more delicate method of investigation to 
disclose a want of power in the periphery of the field consequent on 
impairment of the functions of the nerve-fibres. 

For the sake of conciseness we will class all those symptoms visi- 
ble on the papilla, and which may be present in every conceivable 
degree of the affection, under the head of atrophic degeneration, and 
endeavor to call attention to their practical bearings on the study of 
amaurosis. And, as has been the case with various ophthalmoscopic 
symptoms, the multitudinous inferences drawn from which have been 
greatly cut down by the results of clinical experience, so has it 
proved with regard to atrophic degeneration of the papilla. Tts 
existence has been used to prove the presence of a process necessa- 
rily resulting in blindness, and to a certain extent has been employ, 
ed as a material foundation for amaurosis. We enter a decided 
protest against this attempt at identification. It ignores the fact 
that it is absolutely impossible to tell by looking at an optic nerve 
whether the atrophic degeneration be progressive or stationary, while 
here in reality lies the pith of the whole matter. Such conclusions 
are only allowable when the results of the functional investigation 
and the manner of development of the disease are taken into consi- 
deration. A total absence of atrophic degeneration, consolatory 
though it be under certain circumstances, is not sufficient to exclude, 
among others, the very worst fears (Case VI.). On the other hand, 
the presence of an appreciable amount of atrophic degeneration cer- 
tainly proves a derangement of nutrition, with which is linked a 
functional anomaly ; but even when present in a marked degree, we 
are sometimes able to give a prognosis favorable as far as regards 
ultimate blindness (Cases III. and IV.). 

For the sake of explanation, I must return to the impairments of 
function already spoken of. The coexistence of atrophic degenera- 
tion with a field of vision absolutely normal at its periphery, does 
not necessitate an unfavorable prognosis as far as regards blindness. 
The question, then, becomes one of defects of continuity in the field 
of vision — as, for example, of large central scotomas, a prolonged 


existence of which exercises a perceptible influence on the appear- 
ance of the optic nerve. One of our cases (III.) is an example °* 
this. On the other hand, the presence of atrophic degeneration de- 
cidedly complicates the prognosis as regards recovery, and central 
scotomas thus accompanied are, as a rule, capable of but slight im- 
provement. If the field of vision is relatively normal, the presence 
of atrophic degeneration weighs heavily in the balance ; and tins 
not only because it diminishes the hope of recovery that would 
otherwise exist, but also because the fear of progressive failure of 
vision is thus brought much nearer home. In amblyopia potatorum, 
for example, the appearance of the papilla furnishes an almost en- 
tirely reliable test as to the curability or incurability of the case ; 
the same is true in those cases of amblyopia, with a relatively nor- 
mal field of vision, dependent on chronic meningitis. In connection 
with a review of the course of the disease, which remains to be 
treated of, it entirely settles the matter. If the periphery of the 
field of vision is abnormal, we must make a circumstantial investiga- 
tion. In hemiopia resulting from the paralysis of one tractus opti- 
cus, the presence of a large amount of atrophic degeneration may 
not alter the prognosis (Case IV.). It would be a grave mistake to 
deduce from this a necessary progressive change for the worse. 
Special weight, however, is to be attached to the condition of things 
in certain cases of concentric contraction of the field of vision, 
which admit of a tolerably favorable prognosis in the case of deli- 
cate children, or individuals of a pronounced nervous temperament, 
particularly women, provided the optic nerve has remained normal 
(Case VII.); otherwise, however, may justly give rise to apprehen- 
sion. The absence of any particular symptoms in fresh cases of 
amblyopia or amaurosis, with contraction of the field of vision, 
should not, of course, lead us to indulge in any false feelings of se- 
curity (Case VI.). Such symptoms need some time (occasionally, 
however, only a few weeks) for their development, and accordingly 
not infrequently follow slowly behind the functional failure. On the 
other hand, if the derangement have existed some time without any 
implication of the optic nerve, this fact, taken in connection with the 
other circumstances of the case, may afford us reasonable grounds 
for encouragement. In fact, a grave form of amaurosis, with an 
already considerable impairment of the field and acuteness of vision, 
can hardly have existed several months without having set its seal 


on the papilla. In a case of advanced impairment of vision of long 
duration, the papilla is found entirely intact (putting malinger- 
ing Out of the question) only in those rare and curable cases which 
I denominate proper anaesthesia of the retina. The ascertainment 
of the condition of things in the second eye is of special importance 
in those ominous forms which in the strictest sense deserve the name 
of amaurosis or progressive atrophy. Here a degree of pallor of 
the papilla, perhaps even a sinking below its proper level, may 
sometimes be found in that very early stage, when it needs a strict 
investigation to discover a torpid condition of the retina at the peri- 
phery of the field of vision. 

Other symptoms about the papilla have had importance attributed to them in 
cases of amblyopia. Especially was for a long time an infinite deal said of hy- 
percemia of the papilla, as indicative of the first congestive stage of the disease. 
It is certain that a want of a sufficiently comprehensive survey of the numerous 
physiological variations has caused much that was normal to be looked upon as 
morbid. I have no intention here of detailing the ophthalmoscopic symptoms of 
true hypersemia of the papilla, and will only state that this may help to explain 
the reason of amblyopia (as, for example, in intercranial congestion), but will 
hardly of itself account for a considerable diminution of perception. This refers, 
of course, to anomalies in the fulness of the vessels without any structural 
change. Moreover, hyperaemia of the papilla occurs much more frequently as a 
consequence of undue exertion of the eyes, for example in derangements of the 
accommodation, than in amblyopia, and is entirely absent in the fatal forms of 
progressive atrophy. 

It has also been thought that anomalies in Hie limits of the papilla might be 
found in many cases of amblyopia. A loss of transparency in the connective 
tissue of the superjacent retina, such as often (see above) happens on the papilla 
itself, would in fact cause a loss of distinctness in the margin of the choroid on 
account of the increased retinal reflex. It is a very important fact, however, as 
regards the diagnosis, that this loss of transparency in cases of amblyopia is con- 
fined to the papilla, and depends perhaps on a separate nutrition of its connec- 
tive tissue with implication of those vessels passing over from the choroid (Le- 
ber). If atrophy of the nerve depend on an intra-ocular cause, on choroido-reti- 
nitis, or particularly on neuro-retinitis, the matter becomes a different one, and it 
is then the diminished transparency of the adjacent retina, surrounding the pa- 
pilla with a narrow border or a broader ring (beside changes in the vessels) 
which enable us to watch this method of development for a long time after the 
original process has run its course. 

Finally, a real diminution in the diameter of the papilla has been supposed to 
take place in cases of atrophy, but neither pathological anatomy nor clinical ob- 
servation have ascertained anything of importance in this particular. 

The third chief factor in aiding us to form an opinion in amblyo- 
pic affections is the mode of development of the disease and the accom- 
panying symptoms. To enumerate the many points which are here 


of importance were impossible without going over the entire ground, 
and we will confine ourselves, at least on this occasion, to a few 
practical hints. 

And, first, we observe cases where the trouble developes itself in 
the shape of sharply-defined hemiopic or concentric limitations of 
the field of vision ; also of central scotoma and even of total blind- 
ness, in either case occurring suddenly or very quickly (i. e., in a 
few moments, hours or days). It was in pathology formerly the 
custom to connect any sudden occurrence with a hemorrhagic effu- 
sion, and thus fared these cases. But only those affections where 
the hemiopia occurred on corresponding sides could be ascribed to 
apoplexy in the anatomical sense of the word, and even this connec- 
tion has its exceptions.* 

Where we have to deal with a double central scotoma, with sudden 
blindness of one or both eyes, the hemorrhagic hypothesis is seldom 
admissible. We could, indeed, hardly point out its locality without 
ignoring the information derived up to the present from pathological 
anatomy. If we have other symptoms, indeed, of a preexisting or 
accompanying disease, such as a process at the base of the brain, or 
the products of encephalitis, we are able to give a somewhat definite 
opinion as regards the cause of the sudden derangement of vision. 
But this is by no means generally the case. I have so often seen all 
these forms occur in entire health, and accompanied by symptoms 
otherwise so vague, that I must frankly admit my ignorance in gene- 
ral as to their cause. Their connection with haematemesis, gastric 
derangements, or the acute exanthemata, when they thus occur, is 
still unexplained. An attempt has necessarily been made to take 
refuge in the favorite hypothesis of a vaso-motory influence and spas- 
modic contractions in the vessels thereon dependent ; an hypothesis 
to which some accompanying circumstances in the condition of the 
retina and the general system seem occasionally to give a color. 
Even the fact of a symmetrical development in each retina, or in 
the cerebral source of each, might to a certain extent be plausibly 
explained by nervous influences similarly symmetrical. But when 
shall we succeed in fructifying this treacherous soil with the seed of 
sound fact? The significance and the course of these processes is 

* We may even sec true hemiopia, i. e., want of sensibility of one tractus opticus as an 
accompaniment of migraine, of course distinguishing it from that false hemiopia the see- 
ing halves of ui>jeet^, which sometimes occurs with migraine. 


as uncertain as was their theoretical contemplation. In two cases 
attacked with apparently identical symptoms, there may result com- 
plete recovery, or the affection may persist and atrophy of the optic 
nerve become developed. The prognosis of the disease must, there- 
fore, depend on its progress. Sudden cases of blindness in each 
eye seem to me to result more favorably in children than in adults. 
I shall embrace a favorable opportunity of publishing some facts in 
this connection. An absolute failure of quantitative perception of 
light, occurring in a case of sudden blindness, and having lasted one 
or several weeks, need not necessarily be regarded as hopeless. If it 
lasts longer, and is accompanied by atrophic degeneration of the 
optic nerve, the chance of course diminishes. It is favorable in the 
cases of derangement of vision of sudden occurrence after mental 
excitement, in which are found remarkable variability in the field of 
vision, entire retention of the phosphenes, even in the blind portions 
of the retina, and where absolute darkness exercises a favorable in- 
fluence — a form of anesthesia which sometimes accompanies cutane- 
ous insensibility to pain, and which especially invites a solution on 
a vaso-motory basis. As regards central scotoma of sudden forma- 
tion, I can give neither a cause nor a prognosis. I have seen it both 
disappear and remain fixed ; never, however, lead to blindness when 
once its functional characteristics had for some time maintained 

In comparison with the ordiuary more gradual development, these 
cases of sudden or rapid occurrence must be looked upon as excep- 
tional. Those cases of amblyopia in which the periphery of the field 
of vision proves normal or relatively normal, and the perception 
throughout the continuity of the field satisfactory, ordinarily develop 
themselves during several or many months till they either reach a 
certain point, or, the cause of the disease continuing active, assume 
other forms. Thus in cases where the periphery of the field of 
vision is absolutely normal, if the acuteness of vision continues to 
diminish, a central scotoma — previously impossible to define — be- 
comes gradually developed. Those cases, on the contrary, where 
the field of vision is relatively normal, may pass into the amaurotic 
form with atrophic degeneration of the papilla, the field of vision 
becoming contracted (see above). As a rule, and in contrast with 
genuine atrophy, the affection in these cases which seem more fa- 
vorable at the outset, developes itself equally in each eye. As far 


as regards the chance of ultimate blindness, the fact of the disease 
having remained a long time at the same point is materially lavora- 
ble. The more serious forms are, it is true, liable to interruptions, 
which however, if carefully watched, are seldom found to last more 
than a few months. The fact that for a long time no change 
has occurred need not dampen the hope of recovery, provided the 
optic nerve appears normal, and no contraction of or interruption 
in the field of vision has taken place. On the contrary, we gene- 
rally find these forms may be cured by a proper attention to the 
predominant cause. The immoderate use of alcoholic liquors, fre- 
quent indulgence in strong cigars, pelvic obstructions, catamenial 
derangements, cold extremities, suppression of habitual hemorrhagic 
discharges or of pathological and physiological secretions, venereal 
excesses, irregular sleep and immoderate use of the eyes sometimes 
exert a separate, sometimes a combined effect, and it is then difficult 
to assign each their part.* The more, then, taking a general sur- 
vey of the case, it is possible to ascertain and attend to these causes, 
the more confidently may we pronounce our judgment. If, partly 
from the above-named causes, and partly from some of which we are 
ignorant, symptoms have become developed which render probable the 
existence of a chronic meningitis, such as violent attacks of recur- 
rent headache, with sensibility of the head to the touch, a sense of 
confusion, &c, a more cautious prognosis should be given ; for al- 
though we often succeed in curing such forms of amblyopia by the 
use of powerful derivativef agents, they sometimes, however, assume 
a less favorable type. The same applies to amblyopia, although the 
functional derangement be slight, occurring after severe attacks of 
sickness — for example, after typhus and erysipelas of the head. 

Of particular importance is the process of development in cases 
of. contraction of the field of vision. And here should be stated, 
with reference to hemiopic limitations, that — putting out of the ques- 
tion cases of apoplexy and encephalitis — they may sometimes be 
induced by idiopathic and even transitory affections of an optic nerve 
tract. These generally depend on syphilis, in isolated cases, how- 

* The fact which cannot be denied, that amblyopia affects men more frequently than wo- 
men, the proportion with us being about 4 to 1, has seemed to justify the conclusion that 
smoking is one of the chief causes ; many of the other conditions, however, are especially 
applicable to men, and, in my opinion, excessive smoking must be regarded, in the majori- 
ty of cases, as simply among the active causes. 

f Particularly the scton, which is here especially indicated, not, however, in genuine atro- 
phy. Further, we may use aperients and a course of sublimate. 


ever, certain inexplicable nervous influences come into play, and 
neither the subsequent course of, nor recovery from the disease brings 
them to light. My experience teaches the development of such fa- 
vorable cases to be so relatively rapid that the acme may be reached 
in a few weeks. Similar, but very rare cases of temporal hemiopia, 
of relatively quick development, are observed, in which — to judge 
from the entire subsidence of the symptoms — a transitory affection 
of the fasciculi cruciati must have been the cause. I by no means 
intend to assert that it is always possible to distinguish soon after 
its commencement, between this and the more serious affections ; but 
among the more important criteria for determining this as soon as 
possible, appear to me to be the rapid, as well as nearly simultane- 
ous and symmetrical development in both eyes; the relatively 
acute central vision, which seldom falls below ^ or •£, and the 
entire integrity of the papilla after a lapse of several weeks. 
When within a relatively short time one eye becomes entirely blind, 
while the other for months afterwards remains intact, the prognosis 
with regard to the latter is much more favorable than if the disease 
had progressed insidiously and the first eye perhaps become only 
partially blind. We have in the first instance to refer the atrophy to 
one optic nerve proceeding from the chiasma, inasmuch as it would 
be highly improbable that an affection of the fasciculus lateralis or 
fasciculus cruciatus alone, and not of the contiguous fibres, should 
be in question. 

If considerable derangements of vision, with contractions of the 
field of vision of one kind or another, follow on acute and severe 
cerebral symptoms bearing the type of encephalo-meningitis, we have 
no right to deduce progressive atrophy from either the unfavorable 
functional derangements nor from the atrophic degeneration of the 
papilla. We see, indeed, not infrequently, and in spite of all this, 
that gradual improvement up to a certain permanent point takes 
place. I was consulted a week ago by a person 24 years of age, 
who, at the age of 12, had suffered from a severe affection of the 
brain, as a direct consequence of which, the left eye had become en- 
tirely blind, and the right limited to a small, central field of vision, 
enabling him with much difficulty to find his way about, and to dis- 
tinguish the larger letters. The optic papilla of this eye had under- 
gone important changes ; the functional state, however, during the 


last twelve years, had remained the same. "We must make it, as a 
general rule, the object of a careful examination to decide whether 
the cause of the derangement of vision has passed away or is still 
active. In the first case we often have to do with a result dependent 
on destruction of a portion of the conductive elements, and there is 
hardly a form of amblyopia amaurotica which may not to a certain 
extent be thus regarded. The same considerations apply to the 
question of recovery. Complete blindness may supervene on acute 
cerebral disease, quantitative perception of light may be entirely 
lost for several weeks, or in exceptional cases, even months, and yet 
vision be partially restored. My only intention in stating this is to 
warn against forming a fatal prognosis too quickly. On the other 
hand, illusory hopes must not be indulged in ; if absolute blindness 
have lasted a considerable time and the papilla become degenerated, 
the prospect is extremely bad, and at the best becomes confined to 
the reinstalment of small portions of the field of vision. A marked 
distinction, however, still exists between processes of this class and 
those which progress insidiously and without marked cerebral symp- 
toms, inasmuch as these, in no stage of their development, admit of 
amelioration, and are at the utmost capable of being but temporarily 

The course of the most desperate form of amaurosis is as follows. 
Slowly, but not regularly so, in the course of months or years, the 
field of vision of the first eye becomes contracted (generally irregu- 
larly, laterally), its acuteness of vision diminishes, atrophic degene- 
ration of the papilla takes place, and the organ is lost, while after 
the first eye has begun to be affected, sometimes not till after its 
entire loss, the second commences to run the same course. These 
cases are, indeed, utterly hopeless j they are regarded as a noli me 
tangere by the experienced physician, who cautiously refrains from 
active treatment, knowing that this may easily harm, and at the best 
can be but of little service. 

A few remarks may be added on the nature of amaurosis. Where 
there are no objective intra-ocular symptoms in cases of impaired 
vision, we are apt to speak of cerebral or spinal amaurosis. In the 
more favorable and curable forms of amblyopia there must exist 
anomalies in the circulation or nutrition, to which pathological ana- 
tomy gives in general no satisfactory solution. In those cases, too, 


progressing towards blindness and attended with disorganization 
of the papilla, we arc by no meaus invariably able to find evidences of 
change in the central organs. Atrophy of the nerve-fibre and gan- 
glion-cell layers of the retina is generally found ; at the same time, 
also, atrophy of the optic nerves, sometimes stopping at the chiasma, 
sometimes prolonged beyond, coupled with atrophic alterations in 
the thalami and corpora quadrigemina. If, accordingly, the amau- 
rotic process is to be regarded as no more than a progressive atro- 
phy of the optic nerve and retina, an atrophy the course of which 
— whether towards or from the centre — is still doubtful, it is yet 
undeniable that this partial atrophy is associated in a considerable 
proportion of the cases with a widely diffused affection of the cen- 
tral nervous system, and may therefore be regarded in some cases 
as a remote consequence, in others as simply indicating the region 
in which the disease first makes itself felt. Especially interesting 
is the connection of progressive amaurosis with paralysis and men- 
tal alienation, and thus with gray degeneration of the spinal cord. 
It is well known that amaurotic affections not infrequently supervene 
on disordered states of the intellect; but sufficient stress has not 
been laid upon the fact that a large number of those attacked with 
amaurosis, who were in perfect possession of their faculties when 
first affected, are subsequently the victims of dementia. While, there- 
fore, amaurosis may not infrequently be looked upon as a premoni- 
tory symptom of mental derangement, the reverse is almost without 
exception the case in gray degeneration of the spinal cord. Charac- 
teristic symptoms of the spinal affection (impairment of sensibility) 
have become settled before the advent of the amaurotic affection. 
This may be explained by the anatomical fact that the course of the 
degeneration is from the vertebral column towards the interior of 
the skull. Of all the many cases of spinal amaurosis (forming, as 
they do, some thirty per cent, of the graver forms of progressive 
amaurosis) which came under my observation, I can recollect but 
two instances where the disease progressed in an opposite direction. 
In the one the amaurotic long preceded the spinal affection, the pa* 
tient having been entirely blind five years before the first eccentric 
pains, followed by the usual signs of tabes, made their appearance. 
In the other, the amaurotic affection had also lasted several years 
but at the time of occurrence of the spinal disease there remained 
some perception of light in one eye. 


As many different opinions prevail concerning the minute anatomy 
of progressive atrophy of the optic nerve, as with regard to its 
kindred affection — gray degeneration. Have we to do with a primary 
inflammation in the interstitial connective tissue of the nerve, termi- 
nating in the disappearance of the conductive elements, or are we to 
regard the disease as a genuine atrophy and to consider the connec- 
tive tissue, which has taken the place of the nervous elements, simply 
as a supplementary structure ? Certain symptoms during the course 
of the disease, such as attacks of frontal headache, altered demeanor, 
sleepiness, which often disappear as the blindness progresses, offer 
us a strong inducement to clinically maintain the hypothesis of a 
primary stage of inflammation. Still we must admit that these signs 
allow of a double interpretation, and that the violent eccentric pains 
which accompany tabes dorsalis give much more ground for suppos- 
ing previous inflammation. And jet the fashionable theory of this 
disease inclines more than ever to genuine atrophy. A decision 
based on anatomical grounds, which should be final, is a matter of 
great difficulty, the opportunities of examining the disease in its 
earlier stages being so rare. It may be regarded as a fixed fact 
that there is no question of an inflammation of the nerve connective 
tissue, in the ordinary sense of the word, in amaurosis or tabes dor- 
salis. The best proof of this is furnished by the inspection of the 
optic papilla, a thing possible from the first stage of the disease. 
The changes here are essentially different from those of neuritis, of 
which we may obtain so perfect a picture. But we see that the 
change in the connective tissue is not always the same. Sometimes 
we have a simple loss of substance (atrophic excavation), the most 
perfect type of a true atrophic process ; sometimes there occurs a 
gradual consolidation of the connective tissue (the papilla growing 
smooth, white and opaque, while the lamina cribrosa becomes hid- 
den), in which case the connective tissue may be the seat of some 
very delicate inflammatory process, very different from the ordinary 
one. But enough of this. We have speculated beyond the limits 
allowed by our empirically acquired facts, and ventilated certain ob- 
scure questions more than in the present state of science may be 
profitably done. Let us return to the examination of cases, and at- 
tempt to utilize what has been brought forward in the study of the 
various forms of disease. 


Case I. 

Curative form of Congestive Amblyopia, with Normal Field of T isioiu 

Florian M., railway employee, set. 49, of healthy appearance, 
cheeks and extremity of nose of rather a venous redness, comes on 
account of impaired vision of both eyes. This has been creeping 
on for the last twenty months ; at first very gradually, during the 
last four months, however, has perceptibly increased. The functional 
examination shows that the acuteness of vision (tried by average 
daylight) has fallen in the right eye to |, in the left to \, The peri- 
phery of the field of vision (examined by softened lamplight) proves 
to be absolutely normal, and in accordance with this there can be 
found neither interruptions, misty spots, nor breaks in the acuteness 
of eccentric vision. Inspection discovers nothing abnormal about 
the exterior or interior of the eye ; indeed, in spite of the already 
considerable duration of the disease, the papilla retains its delicate 
red, semi-transparent color. 

Its nasal segment is appreciably more reddened than the temporal, owing to 
the greater number of small vessels and the thicker layer of nerve-fibre in the 
first direction. To this may be added that the inner is not so sharply defined as 
the outer edge of the choroid, still a careful inspection reveals the whole contour. 
Such a condition of the papilla may be regarded as entirely physiological, provi- 
ded nothing abnormal be found in the vessels and the tissue. It is more or less 
marked, according to natural varieties in the optic nerve, and shows best gene- 
rally in a case of physiological excavation. The larger veins are well filled, but 
are not abnormally tortuous, either as regards their own axis or the plane of the 
retina. We cannot, then, consider this as a symptom of disease ; all the less, in 
fact, because the patient's complexion bears evidence of habitual venous en- 

An investigation of the case shows that the patient has for a long 
time indulged moderately in brandy, drank large quantities of beer, 
smoked considerably, and had his rest broken by the duties of his 
calling. He has suffered from neither digestive nor cerebral dis- 
turbance, and enjoyed good health. The result of the examination 
of the organs of respiration and circulation, the pelvic viscera, the 
skin and the urine is negative. 

As regards the jwognosis of this case, we may venture on an opin- 
ion in every respect favorable. In the first place, a progressive 
blindness is not to be feared in the least ; for in spite of the long 
continuance of the disease the boundaries of the field of vision 


prove to be entirely normal. But we may even speak confidently of 
improvement and restoration of vision, for (1) the continuity of the 
field of vision is entirely uninterrupted ; it is only an affair of gene- 
ral diminution of sensitiveness, no indication of a central scotoma 
being present; (2) the appearance of the optic papilla is unchanged; 
notwithstanding the difficulty has lasted two years, there is no trace 
of atrophic degeneration; (3) in the habits of life of the patient we 
find palpable causes, amenable to therapeutic influences, and of a 
kind that experience teaches us may produce derangements capable, 
to a certain extent, of removal. 

It would be a difficult task to accurately explain the nature of this 
affection. No signs of active cerebral congestion exist. The ve- 
nous redness of the face and the predisposing causes render proba- 
ble a so-called passive congestion ; this expression, however, conveys 
but a limited amount of information. Suppose the case to be one of 
an inundation of the central nervous structures with venous blood, 
or of a want of rapidity in the movement and change of the blood 
itself, or let there be a diminished activity of function on account of 
the blood being overloaded with alcoholic and narcotic substances — 
every one of these suppositions would be explained on the ground 
of " passive congestion of the brain." The only general and satis- 
factory use of this term is, therefore, in cases where, there being no 
signs of active congestion, the functional as well as the nutritive 
activity of the cerebral centre of the optic nerve has been reduced by 
influences springing from the source alluded to and acting through 
the circulation. 

How is the cure of the case to be effected ? First, of course, by 
paying a proper regard to its cause. The use of alcoholic beverages 
must be given up, that of tobacco reduced to a minimum, regularity 
in diet and sleep insisted on. Not infrequently is this course alone 
sufficient to cause a gradual retrogression of the symptoms in cases 
of this form of amblyopia. Experience teaches us, however, that 
there are more efficient means of securing and hastening a favora- 
ble result. As regards local depletion, a rapid evacuation of the blood 
is here of special importance. I was some time since led by this 
to appreciate the application of the leech of Heurteloup in the treat- 
ment of congestive amblyopia, and the method based on this has 
found much favor with the profession. 


A good deal depends here on the manner of application. If the operator to 
whom we commit the task is not competent to fill a cylinder in a few minutes, the 
particular advantage* of this method is lost. The application must be made in 
the evening, so as to give the full benefit of the night's rest. It is, moreover, de- 
sirable in many cases that the patient should preserve perfect quiet the next day 
and remain in a dark room. As the importance of this precaution in such case 
depends on a careful consideration of the individual circumstances, it is best to 
regard it as a general rule. It is of consequence on account of the excitability of 
the cerebral circulation, or — if preferred — of the vaso-motory nerves. In cases 
where this is considerable, each application is followed by a period of excitement, 
characterized by derangements of sensibility of every kind, sometimes by subject- 
ive appearances of light, and even by some diminution of the acuteness of vision. 
This period of " reaction," lasting only in exceptional cases more than a day, 
should be prepared for by entire bodily rest and a strict seclusion from light. This 
state, moreover, is least marked in cases of amblyopia arising from passive cere- 
braL congestion, and most so in certain affections of the choroid ; the period of rest, 
therefore, is less indispensable in the former case than in the latter. From two to 
four ounces of blood should be taken at each application. And this should be 
repeated at intervals of four, six or eight days, according to the constitution of 
the patient and the. duration of the period of reaction. A careful examination of 
the acuteness of vision instituted directly prior to and two days after the applica- 
tion (the period of reaction being thus passed) will decide the propriety of repe- 
tition. Where the acuteness of vision has not been affected by two, at the most 
by three applications, they should be omitted. But even where a perceptible 
effect is noticed, I do not advise a too frequent repetition in cases of passive ce- 
rebral congestion, although of course the state of the constitution must influence 
the decision in individual cases. For it has been ascertained that those cases 
which evince improvement after the first three or four bloodlettings, do better 
under diaphoretics than by a continuance of the abstraction of blood, and it is our 
duty — other things being equal — to give the first named the preference as a less 
severe course. f 

* Be it said, in this connection, that the Heurteloup leech, rendering, as it does, mos t 
valuable service in congestive amblyopia and chronic affections of the choroid, is by no 
means as good as the natural one in the treatment of the different forms of ophthalmia. It is 
here that we derive more advantage from a prolonged suction and a continuous flow of 
blood than from the rapidity with which it is lost. 

f Although warmly recommending the Heurteloup leech in cases of amblyopia with 
passive cerebral congestion, I am willing to admit that some cases derive more benefit from 
other measures. This is especially the fact when the excitability of the circulation is ex- 
tremely pronounced. Here the period of reaction is seen to be abnormally lengthened and 
indisposed to yield to the desired remission. In such cases a decidedly better result is often 
obtained from cupping in the neck, in hemorrhoidal affections from leeches to the anus, and 
in disorders of menstruation from cupping on the inside of the thighs ; indeed, under these 
circumstances the Heurteloup leech may eyen increase the disturbance and harm the case- 
The question so often raised in practice as to whether the removal of blood shall take place 
from the immediate vicinity or at some distance from the affected part, depends in a 
measure on the method employed, and especially on the degree of excitability, and conside- 
rable caution must be used in answering the question in the first sense. A common mistake 


Our diaphoretic treatment was principally (in imitation of many 
older practitioners) carried out by means of the decoction of Zitt- 
mann, not because any specific effect is to be attributed to the sepa- 
rate ingredients of this complex draught, but because experience has 
shown it to be an excellent diaphoretic of proved worth. The 
strong decoction, warmed, was therefore given at an early hour to the 
patient in bed, and its action on the skin assisted by means of wool- 
len coverings and afterwards by elder-tea, while on the other hand 
no special restrictions with regard to diet, as is generally the cus- 
tom when this preparation is used, were imposed on the patient; a 
walk, too, in the afternoon was allowed when the weather was fa- 
vorable. Of late we have been more sparing in the employment of 
the decoction of Zittmann, having learned to recognize a thoroughly 
invaluable therapeutic agent in well-appointed Roman baths.* 

The patient was again presented at the clinique four weeks after 
the commencement of his treatment. His course of life had been 
regulated and the Heurteloup leech applied three times, in conse- 
quence of which his acuteness of vision had successively increased 
from £ on one side and } on the other to | on each. Following this, 
a Roman bath had been taken every three days. No result followed 
the first bath, except a headache which lasted twelve hours, owing 
to the fact that he had not remained long enough in the sweating 
room and had been disturbed by the application of a cold douche at 
the wrong time. The next baths, in the administration of which 
these points were attended to, produced an excellent result, the 
acuteness of vision having risen, after the fifth had been taken, on 

in cases of ophthalmia is to place the leeches nearer the eye than consorts with the sensitive- 
ness of this organ and the surrounding structures. Further individual circumstances may 
sometimes induce us to employ other applications in preference to the Heurteloup leech on 
the temple, as when the disease seems, for example, to be connected with the cessation of 
habitual epistaxis, or of a hemorrhoidal flow, &c. 

* My first inducement to employ Roman baths in cases of amblyopia with passive cere- 
bral congestion was furnished me by a patient who had been but moderately benefited by a 
course of decoction of Zittmann, and who entirely cured himself of his amblyopia by re- 
maining in the warm boiling-room of a sugar-factory, the heat being nearly 40 Q (122 Q Fah- 
renheit). Great advantages as the Roman baths possess in most of these cases over the 
Russian baths, they have, of course, their contra-indications, among them the more active 
states of congestion, and especially cardiac and renal affections, an apoplectic tendency 
and undue excitability of the circulation. 

[These " Roman baths " are known in this country as Turkish baths, and differ from the 
Russian in the employment of dry heat instead of vapor.— Translator.] 


the right to §, on the left to more than £. A speedy and entire re- 
covery is therefore no longer doubtful. 

Von Graefe remarks, in conclusion, as follows. Recovery does 
not follow as rapidly in all these cases of amblyopia as in the pre- 
sent. If, however, appropriate treatment succeeds in once causing 
the affection to take such a turn that the acuteness of vision begins 
to increase, we may reckon with nearly entire confidence on a gra- 
dual and almost spontaneous improvement, provided the cause of 
the difficulty continues to be avoided. The attempt must not, there- 
fore, be made to perfect the result by continuing the employment of 
vigorous measures during a prescribed time, but rather, after the first 
blow has been administered to the disease, it should be left to itself 
awhile, after which the former treatment may be resumed. Thus 
the entire amount of previous vision may often be seen to return in 
the space of several months or more. On the other hand, a strong 
tendency to relapse may be manifested, when, owing to a faltering 
resolution or the pressure of circumstances, the patients again come 
within the influence of the previous exciting cause of the disease ; in 
fact, such relapses may exhibit a paralytic tendency, differing from 
the previously mild form (as in the case of amblyopia potatorum). 
This teaches us how necessary it is to lay particular stress on the 
manner of life of such patients and regulate their labor. Finally, 
be it remarked that while we very frequently employ the course that 
has here proved itself efficacious, it should by no means be regarded 
as the exclusive method of treatment in such forms of the affection. 
No cases need more individual study than those of amblyopia, and 
the physician who after a single and hasty survey undertakes to 
give such patients advice available for some time to come, commits 
a serious fault. The derangements in the circulation which are here 
concerned may spring from the most varied sources, and it is both 
perilous and narrow-minded to deduce them by preference from 
some particular organic affection, from the liver, for example, or the 
alimentary canal, or some irregular course of life. Abdominal dis- 
orders, it is true, often play a principal part among the causes, and 
in accordance with this view, we often see good effects resulting 
from the use of mineral springs, such as Marienbad, Kissingen, Hom- 
burg, and in suitable cases particularly Carlsbad; as a general 
thing, however— thanks to the prevailing tendency — the functions of 
the abdominal viscera occupy too exclusively the attention of the 



physician. The weighty functions of the skin and kidneys, so im- 
portant in their effect on amblyopic affections, are among those seri- 
ously neglected through this preference. While the regularity and 
amount of the faecal evacuations are anxiously dwelt upon, these 
principal regulators of the circulation are hardly regarded, as be- 
ing of minor importance. Even the ways of life, from which but 
too often proceed the accumulated causes of derangement of the 
circulation, are often but carelessly scanned by the physician, and 
as a matter of course made light of by the patient. If the sleep be 
not particularly disturbed, little is said about it, and yet good and 
regular sleep affords the most grateful refreshment to the unceas- 
iugly active nerve of vision. To be here a successful physician, one 
must examine with extreme care and weigh the result with foresight 
and impartiality. 

Case II. 
Progressive Amaurosis, depending on Atrophy of the Optic Nerves. 

Julius M., a sailor, set. 24, of tolerably robust appearance and a 
healthy complexion, presents himself on account of a considerable 
impairment cf vision, rendering it already difficult for him to find 
his way about. According to his own account, the left eye became 
affected six months, the right four months ago, and in both the rate 
of progression has been tolerably equal. At present the acuteness 
of central vision amounts to about T ^ on the left side, -^ on the 
right ; it should be stated, however, that in the left eye the acuteness 
of vision in the direction upwards and outwards is not only rela- 
tively but absolutely greater than in that of fixation, so that while 
fingers are with difficulty counted at a distance of nine inches when 
held directly before the patient, they are made out in two feet if 
held at an angle of 20° from the point of fixation. This agrees 
entirely with the following state of the field of vision. In the left 
eye the entire inner half is wanting, and a hand held up in good 
daylight is nowhere visible on the farther side of the vertical line of 
equal division. In the outer and lower quadrant, too, eccentric 
vision is extremely imperfect, and becomes entirely defective by re- 
duced lamplight. It is only relatively good in the outer and upper 
quadrant, and is here in one direction more pronounced than in cen- 
tral vision, as is seen in the tendency to eccentric fixation. A bet- 
ter functional state is found in the right eye. The loss in the field 


of vision, proceeding here, too, from the inner edge, does not extend 
to the vertical line of equal division, but remains in the plane of 
vision about 15° from the point of fixation. Below the plane of 
vision, indeed, it approaches nearer this vertical line, while above it 
recedes from it. A considerable failure of distinctness in the eccen- 
tric vision extends, however, far beyond these limits, it being impos- 
sible to count fingers in the immediate vicinity of the nasal side of 
the point of fixation. In accordance with this, the defective region 
nearly grazes the point of fixation, by diminished lamplight. In the 
outer half of the field the eccentric acuteness of vision is relatively, 
although here not absolutely, better than the central. The conside- 
rable loss of perception, and especially the contraction of the field 
of vision, is manifested in the unsteady, tentative gait of the patient. 
As the light wanes, he becomes entirely helpless, owing to the above- 
mentioned torpidity of the retina, existing, as it does, within a 
large portion of the already contracted field of vision. 

With the exception of the sluggish pupillary reaction, especially 
marked on the left side, nothing abnormal is externally visible. The 
ophthalmoscope reveals a normal state of the refractive media and 
internal membranes, and in each eye a high degree of atrophic 
degeneration of the papilla, under the form of atrophic excava- 
tion. The elements of the lamina cribrosa are plainly visible 
in the larger and excavated portion of the papilla, on the temporal 
side up to the edge. The remaining substance of the papilla, name- 
ly, inwards from the vessels, is of an opaque whiteness ; the smaller 
vessels are wanting ; those of medium size are somewhat, the larger, 
on the other hand, hardly at all contracted. 

An examination of the case shows that, at the commencement of 
the change in his vision, the patient suffered from slight frontal head- 
ache, increased by stooping and coupled with a sense of confusion j 
that for several months, however, these, at the best but slightly pro- 
nounced symptoms, have entirely disappeared. At present no trace 
of disease is to be found in either any organ or in the physical or 
mental functions. He labors, naturally, at present under some men- 
tal depression ; no more, however, than might reasonably be attri- 
buted to the daily failure in his vision. Nothing of consequence 
can be ascertained from his previous habits of life, except a not im- 
moderately excessive use of tobacco, which, however, he gave up at 
the first commencement of the trouble. 


The prognosis of this case is altogether a gloomy one. The con- 
traction of the field of vision has taken place in that ominous man- 
ner which characterizes progressive atrophy : slowly advancing limi- 
tation from the inner edge, first on the left side, then symmetrically 
on the right, besides enormous loss of sight, which has caused on 
the left side an absolute, and on the right a relative preponderance 
of eccentric over central vision. 

Before, however, giving up all hope, it is our duty to think over 
all the possible relatively favorable chances, if necessary to exclude 
them. May we not, perhaps, have to do with one of those cases 
(already referred to) of contraction of the field of vision resulting 
from hemiopia, and in which recovery is possible ? Unfortunately, 
our reply must be in the negative ; for in the first place the affection 
has extended on the left side far beyond the vertical line of equal 
division ; in the second, the acuteness of vision at the point of fixa- 
tion has become, even on the right side, too much affected ; in the 
third, the defective portion of the field is not sharply set apart from 
the parts that retain their normal function, but is bounded by exten- 
sive portions, the acuteness of vision of which is reduced and the 
torpor typical ; fourthly, the development, although more rapid than 
in the average of cases of progressive atrophy, cannot properly be 
called acute, i. e., reaching its height in a few weeks ; fifthly, we 
have to do with limitations of the inner portion of the field on each 
side, whereas such curable or stationary cases have thus far been 
observed to take the form of hemiopia either temporal or occurring 
on corresponding sides (very seldom that of defective portions ex- 
tending upwards or downwards). May not this, we ask again, be 
perhaps the result of an action already terminated or capable of being 
arrested, and may it not on this theory be possible to keep what vision 
exists at present or save an appreciable portion? Neither the 
course of the disease nor the attendant symptoms support this view. 
In the case of rapidly-developed amaurotic disorders, accompanied 
by well-marked cerebral symptoms, the subsidence of which leaves 
the affection stationary, we have a more favorable foundation to 
build upon ; such is, however, not here the case, the vague indie a- 
tions of cerebral disturbance which previously existed have passed 
away without making the least impression on the continued develop- 
ment of the amaurosis. In this point of view, its steady increase 
is discouraging. The less the connection that can be mad e out with 


ulterior cerebral symptoms that possibly admit of relief, the more 
the atrophy of the optic nerve plays the part, so to speak, of an in- 
dependent disease, the more desperate is the prognosis. It is, how- 
ever, made less certain by the discovery of some particular, habit or 
way of life of the patient that is manifestly productive of mischief; 
if we have reason to trust that the removal of this may affect the 
progress of the disease. But even under these circumstances let no 
illusory hopes be indulged in. Has the amaurotic affection passed 
into the stage of advanced contraction of the field of vision, and 
has besides marked degeneration of the papilla taken place, the se- 
condary disease may be known to have attained a fatal indepen- 
dence of its cause. But no fact favorable to our case can be made 
out in this connection. The only suspicious habit, the undue use of 
tobacco, had been relinquished at the commencement of the disease. 
Even in the worst cases of progressive atrophy, it may exception- 
ally happen that an unexpected pause occurs, after the acuteness of 
vision has appreciably diminished. I saw, for example, within a few 
days a patient who had been treated by me for spinal amaurosis 
eight years before. Vision had at that time become extinct in one 
eye, and within a year the other had lost so much as to be only able 
to follow the movements of a hand held on the temporal side. By 
referring to the notes I took at the time, I have recently ascertained 
that this state of the vision, poor as it was, had remained unaltered 
during the space of eight years. Such decided pauses are, however, 
most exceptional, and I have hardly observed them except in cases 
where vision had been reduced to its lowest ebb, where, indeed, in 
the popular sense, blindness might be said to have already commenc- 
ed. They are to be distinguished from the temporary pauses which 
last some weeks, rarely from four to six months. These latter hap- 
pen very frequently, and in the most varied forms of progressive 
amblyopia, especially those dependent on spinal disease. But in 
our case the advanced atrophic degeneration of the papilla, with the 
continuous loss in the field of vision and the failure of all other 
symptoms, offer no foundation for these hopes. And although we 
are withheld by the variable and obscure nature of these affections 
from expressing with too absolute certainty an opinion unfavorable 
to the possible preservation of a very slight amount of vision, per- 
haps quantitative perception of light, it is still most probable that 
within a few months, perhaps a little longer, the patient will become 
the prey of absolute blindness. 


As regards the nature of the disease, it is, in fact, impossible for 
us to make any other diagnosis than that of progressive atrophy of 
the optic nerves. At present, no symptoms of any other morbid 
change are to be found. The paroxysms of headache the patient 
had at the commencement of the disease, and which in an entirely 
analogous manner are met with in many amaurotic .conditions, do 
not in my opinion afford special indications of an existing irritation 
in the substance of the brain or in its membranes. I am inclined to 
explain many such headaches on the ground of the disordered func- 
tions of the eyes themselves. When patients begin to lose their 
vision, and yet concentrate all their faculties on the appreciation of 
their visual impressions in order to follow their avocations or guide 
themselves about, there result derangements of sensibility similar 
to those occurring in diplopia, seeing in circles of dispersion, &c. 
In such cases we observe that the headache disappears as soon as 
the patient intermits his efforts to see. If, however, in the face of 
this, the atrophy or its cause progresses, we have no longer a right 
to directly connect the headache with the cause alluded to. This, 
of course, applies only to certain forms of headache, and the true 
state of the matter must be decided by a review of the whole case, 
especially by trying the effect of entire darkness. In the present 
instance we had nothing on which to base our researches, inasmuch 
as the headache had already disappeared. 

That a headache, caused in the first instance by attempts to see, should be in- 
creased by stooping, or anything inducing congestion, is of course not surprising. 
I am willing, too, to grant that the headache itself may be regarded as conges- 
tive, so far as the efforts at vision are propagated along the vaso-motory nerves, 
as may be best seen in the conjunctival vessels. I merely wish to call attention 
to this point, that the accompanying headache is not always connected with the 
cause of the amaurotic affection, but may directly depend on the derangement 
of vision. In other cases of atrophy paroxysms of pain occur, unconnected with 
the act of vision and evidently attributable to the cause of the malady. Here, 
too, it remains an open question as to its original inflammatory nature, inasmuch 
as it seems that the source of such paroxysms may be found as well in genuine 
atrophy of isolated segments of the brain as in the so nearly-allied gray degene- 
ration of the spinal cord. Finally, I am not disposed to deny that in cases of 
amaurosis complicated with chronic meningitis, there may occur pains character- 
ized as inflammatory by the sensibility of the head to the touch, a strongly-mark- 
ed confusion of the faculties — also by the duration and course of the attacks ; 
but I do not regard such a state of things as either regular or frequent in pro- 
gressive atrophy of the optic nerves. 

In the case of this patient there exist at present no symptoms of 


paralysis of body or mind, and this fact renders it our duty not to 
venture beyond the diagnosis of atrophy of the optic nerve. But 
will it be so in the future ? It is exceedingly possible that in the 
course of years mental alienation may become developed, or some 
further affection of the general system of a paralytic nature. Though, 
however, this sequence is not infrequently observed, it is still the 
fact that more than half the cases of amaurosis do not advance be- 
yond the narrow limits of the special affection, and that when death 
occurs after a lapse of years, an examination reveals either atrophy 
of the optic nerves or partial atrophy of the portions of the brain 
connected with them. 

As to anything additional on the score of treatment, it is simply ne- 
cessary to state that all powerful derivative agents, cathartics, setons, 
mercurials, diaphoretics and depletives, beneficial as they may be in 
cases of congestive amblyopia (Case I.), are here decidedly injurious. 
The more we distinguish the different forms the more will this convic- 
tion force itself upon us. Everything that suddenly depresses the 
strength or excites the circulatory system is to be most carefully 
avoided. We must, however, cease to act on these principles when an 
investigation of the case causes us to arrive at opposite conclusions, 
by demonstrating, for example, the existence of chronic meningitis or 
the suppression of habitual secretions ; but even then (considering 
the state of paralysis that exists) care must be taken that the reme- 
dies employed, such as leeches behind the ears, setons and sublimate, 
be so administered as not to cause sudden depression of the powers. 
In the average of cases of progressive atrophy, the best means of 
retarding its progress consists in a mild tonic course — small doses 
of iron, salt and tonic baths, milk and whey diet ; in other words, a 
nutritious but not stimulating diet, good air, a moderate course of 
cold bathing and a carefully-regulated amount of light. 

In general, a case like the present may be regarded as a noli me 
tangere. We have a right to look upon it with the same dread with 
which the physicians of other days approached an amaurosis. An 
inevitable experience it is, indeed, to the ophthalmic surgeon to find 
such patients leaving their homes and undertaking long journeys in 
the hope of finding succor j returning, as they certainly must, having 
accomplished nothing, and often much blinder than before. Such 
an event has a very depressing effect on the spirits of the patients, 
not only because their hopes have failed of fruition, but also because 


gradual loss of vision is relatively more endurable under the circum. 
stances and exposed to the influences of every-day life. 

Case III. 

Central Scotoma, with partial Atrophy of the Optic Nerve, admit- 
ting only of gradual and partial Improvement. 

Alexander K., aged 20, a coachman, and of tolerably robust ap- 
pearance, comes to us on account of impaired vision of the left eye, 
coming on, as he states, five months ago, and taking but a few weeks 
to attain its present development. The right eye, too, sees but im- 
perfectly ; this, however, he says has always been the case. 

The functional examination reveals, first, an entirely normal con- 
dition of the boundaries of each field of vision; the acuteness of 
vision, however, is reduced in the left eye to -£$, in the right to about 
Jjy, owing to the presence of central scotomas, which subtend an arc 
of from 8° to 10 q in the centre of the field. By ordinary light the 
patient finds it difficult to define these scotomas j by a moderate 
amount of artificial light, however, he is abundantly able, and it be- 
comes manifest that the amount of vision just referred to is eccen- 
tric, inasmuch as within the limits of the central scotoma the patient 
has but a quantitative perception of light. In making the ophthal- 
moscopic examination, it is found that a small image of the flame, 
reflected by means of a plane mirror on the region of the fovea cen- 
tralis, awakens but a feeble impression. The scotomas are surround- 
ed by a ring-shaped zone where vision is defective, broader on the 
inner than on the temporal side. 

We hence arrive at the conclusion that the affection of the right 
eye is by no means congenital, but a matter of recent development, 
probably simultaneous with that of the left. It is possible that the 
patient did not notice its coming on, from the fact of this eye being 
excluded from the act of common vision through a slight divergent 
strabismus. For amblyopia resulting from exclusion never assumes 
the shape of central scotoma. In the lighter forms it is character- 
ized by an equal loss of sensitiveness (diminution of central and 
eccentric vision, especially the former) j in the more serious cases, 
those occurring with persistent strabismus, by a predominance of 
the inner over the outer portion of the retina. 

The ophthalmoscope reveals an entirely normal state of the re- 
fractive media and membranes, a physiological excavation (extend- 


ing here but a short distance outwards from the point of emergence 
of the vessels) ; over and above this, however, an undeniably whitish 
coloration of the papilla, caused by disappearance of the smaller 
vessels and a small loss of transparency in the tissue, a slight degree, 
therefore, of atrophic degeneration. Nothing was obtained from a 
general physical examination. Shortly after this difficulty commenc- 
ed, the patient had attacks of dizziness and headache, recurring 
sometimes and lasting even several days ; entirely disappearing, how- 
ever, during the last few months. 

An entirely favorable prognosis, as far as regards the danger of 
ultimate blindness, may here be given. As has already been stated, 
central scotoma, coupled with a field of vision the limits of which 
are entirely normal, never indicates progressive atrophy. If the 
disease is in its incipient stage, it is well not to lay too much stress 
on this fact ; not so, however, in a case like the present, where the 
form is well marked and the affection has culminated. Deteriora- 
tion, too, is not to be feared. Central scotomas either occur very 
suddenly, or else they become developed in a few weeks simultane- 
ously or successively in both eyes, increasing outwards from their 
own centres (not always proceeding straight from the point of fixa- 
tion) j or finally, cases of amblyopia of more prolonged duration, 
and in which no interruption of the field of vision had been observ- 
ed, develope at a later period signs of central scotoma after such a 
manner that while, as a rule, the existing central acuteness of vision 
is retained, the eccentric improves up to a certain point. We may 
assume, in all these cases of central scotoma, that where the same 
state of things has persisted for several months a change for the 
worse is improbable. The undeniable change in color of the papil- 
la, which is yet to be discussed, by no means necessarily denotes a 
danger of progressive atrophy (see above). Is the prognosis, then, 
favorable as regards a worse condition of things, or blindness, the 
same is not the case as relates to recovery. If central scotomas 
have lasted beyond a few weeks, and visible degeneration of the 
papilla has taken place, an expectation of complete recovery is no 
longer to be indulged in. In general, a slow improvement takes place, 
sometimes hardly perceptible and always imperfect, the blank caused 
by the scotoma becoming smaller, and the surrounding ring-shaped 
zone, where vision was imperfect, gaining in power, while practice 
gives eccentric vision a more than normal amount of acuteness. It 

6 ? 


sometimes happens, too, that in the middle of the central scotoma 
itself a patch clears away, thus allowing of a satisfactory amount of 
central vision. (This last event, however, occurs much less fre- 
quently than in certain cases of central scotoma resulting from cir- 
cumscribed choroido-retinitis, well known to all.) Particularly im- 
portant in making up the prognosis is a knowledge of the fact whether 
vision is relatively most acute centrally, within the scotoma itself, or in 
an adjoining region. In the case of a scotoma, the angle of aper- 
ture of which is 20°, and where vision of T V corresponds with the 
point of fixation — the patient " seeing through the spot " — the prog- 
nosis as regards recovery is much better than where a scotoma with 
a small angle of aperture coexists with vision T ^ which is eccentric, 
i. e., is situated in a region adjoining the scotoma. It is easy to 
understand that a disease interrupting the transmission of impres- 
sions must be much more grave when it brings about a loss of cen- 
tral vision. It has already been stated that this is the condition of 
things in the present case, and this circumstance, in connection with 
the fact that the disease has for some time remained at nearly the 
same level, and degeneration of the papilla has taken place, leads us 
to infer that at the utmost there may result an almost imperceptible 
improvement in the first sense alluded to. Whether our patient 
will, in the course of time, be again in a condition to read ordinary 
type is a matter of uncertainty. 

It is particularly difficult here to enter more minutely into the 
question of diagnosis. Pathological anatomy has as yet furnished 
us with no data in such cases of central scotoma, and clinical obser- 
vation gives us but little theoretical instruction. The fact that both 
eyes are affected, while other symptoms of central disturbance are 
wanting, has caused preference to be given to the theory of the ex- 
istence of some morbid process in the chiasma nervorum opticorum ; 
such an hypothesis, however, I think rests here on slight grounds. 
Were some material cause, such as apoplexy or impairment of sub- 
stance, located in the chiasma, the symmetrical character of the 
affection would seem to me entirely incomprehensible. It appears 
to me much more probable that a defined canse of the disease holds 
sway at the cerebral extremity of the optic nerves, and that these 
regions feel the influence of that symmetrical tendency that governs 
twin organs of sense, and is often so strikingly shown in the exter- 
nal portions of the eye. But to what particular derangement can we 


bring the affair home ? The instantaneous occurrence of scotomas 
has caused them to be attributed to hemorrhagic causes. Against 
this may be set the limited extent of the affection, as well as its 
more gradual development in otherwise analogous cases. Moreover, 
this state of things is never found in connection with other hsemor- 
rhagic diseases of the brain, and is ascertained to relatively occur 
with most frequency in young patients, with whom the principal pre- 
disposing causes of cerebral haemorrhage are absent. It is not im- 
possible that we have to do with anomalies of another kind in the 
circulation, with a stimulation affecting certain points of the vaso- 
motory nervous chain, or, in general, with a functional (molecular ?) 
interruption of the transmission of impressions, the first approach 
of which we are unable to trace to any palpable material cause. 
The subsequent degeneration of the papilla is consistent with this 
theory, inasmuch as it is to be regarded as probably consecutive. If 
we suppose the disease to have proceeded from causes of a vaso- 
motory nature, its symmetrical occurrence at the inner end of each 
optic nerve would admit of ready explanation. It would thus, too, 
be rendered comprehensible why central scotomas should sometimes 
form after an exhausting disease of the entire system, with other 
signs of vaso-motory disturbance ; or after mental affections, with 
absence of cutaneous sensibility. 

The foundation of our diagnosis being thus uncertain, our choice 
of remedies must be based principally on the state of the constitu- 
tion, as also on the causes and accompaniments of the disease. If 
the affection is recent, or if there are symptoms of cerebral conges- 
tion, it would be well to try the effect of a few local bloodlettings, 
by applying leeches behind the ears or the Heurteloup to the tem- 
ple. Where hsemorrhoidal or catamenial complications are suspect- 
ed, they of course deserve consideration. If symptoms of mental 
derangement manifest themselves in connection with the disease, or 
if cutaneous sensibility becomes impaired, a course of zinc or nitrate 
of silver should be prescribed. If the skin fulfils its functions ir- 
regularly, the effect of a powerful diaphoretic — a Roman bath, for 
example — should be tried, if no contra-indications exist. If, on the 
other hand, central scotoma has been developed in the course of a 
prostrating disease, a tonic course is indicated — small doses of iron, 
warm baths, nourishing food, residence in the country, &c. "We 
cannot boast of having found any special course of treatment indi- 


cated in the case of our patient. His previous attacks of giddiness 
and headache admit the supposition of congestive antecedents, al- 
though susceptible of other explanations. 

The patient was shown again two months later. Several local 
abstractions of blood had meanwhile been made, and a diaphoretic 
course carried out. The improvement noticed consisted in an in- 
creased energy of the indistinct region surrounding the scotoma ; 
without any particular change in the scotoma itself. In consequence 
of this the acuteness of vision (still eccentric) had increased to ^ 
on one side and T \ on the other. The patient was now to com- 
mence systematic practice of the eyes. For such cases prove that 
the standard of eccentric vision is set by the amount of its employment, 
and that the capacity of that portion of the retina adjacent to its cen- 
tre is capable of being developed beyond the normal bounds. Without 
ever attaining the normal acuteness of the retinal centre, eccentric 
vision may double and treble itself in cases of central interruption. 
This development may be partially instinctive, brought about by the 
use of the eyes, and partially promoted by systematic practice. We 
give patients, the acuteness of whose vision is insufficient, ordinary 
type to read, and then generally magnifying glasses of unusual 
construction, and based, I think, on a sound principle. Two convex 
glasses — in this case -J- \ and -j- \ were selected — are placed an 
inch apart in a short metallic tube, and the whole furnished with an 
appropriate handle. We thus secure a considerable amount of mag- 
nifying power in connection with less spherical aberration, and a re- 
moval to a better distance from the eye than in the case of ordinary 
convex glasses. I need not add that this system of practice should 
be restricted at first to a very short time, perhaps two minutes, and 
to a size of type not barely recognizable, but seen with some de- 
gree of readiness. 

Case IV. 

Cerebral Hemiopia, occurring on similar Sides, stationary, resulting 

from an Apoplectic Attack. 

August K., weaver of fine cloth, 68 years old, comes to us on account 
of deranged sight, consisting partly in double vision, partly in a 
diminution of the power of distinct perception. An examination 
shows the double vision to depend on a paralysis of the right abdu- 
cens. The power of motion of the right eye outwards is reduced 


2'" in comparison with that of the left, the patient having, accord- 
ingly, homonymous double images, the distance between which in- 
creases towards the right. The remaining derangement of vision 
consists in a slight diminution of its acuteness in each eye to 1, and 
in an entirely symmetrical anomaly of the field of vision. This is 
considerably contracted in each eye on the left side ; eccentric vision 
is, moreover, indistinct over the whole left half, well up to the verti- 
cal line of equal division. Inasmuch as the ophthalmoscopic exa- 
mination reveals no morbid change, except a partial atrophy of the 
optic nerve (to be referred to hereafter), this hemiopia of the left 
side must consequently be referred to a paralysis of the right tractus 
opticus, and the diagnosis of the whole disease may, therefore, be 
set forth as a paralysis of the right abducens and a paralysis of the 
right tractus opticus. A general examination reveals considerable 
and extensive arterio-sclerosis, hypertrophy of the left ventricle and 
insufficiency of the aortic valves. 

From an analysis of the case we gather the following facts. 
Rather more than three years ago, the patient had an apoplectic at- 
tack, which resulted in hemiplegia as also hemiopia on the left side. 
He was under our treatment at that time, and the records show that 
the hemiopia, which at first had been nearly complete (failure of the 
field of vision up to the vertical line of equal division), gave way 
during the convalescence to the present point, the acuteness of vision 
rising from £ to £. Consequently, since that time, his power of sight 
has remained entirely the same. Fourteen days ago, the patient 
was compelled to go out in great haste with uncovered head in the 
midst of a snow storm, got into a profuse perspiration, the next 
morning had an acute, though not very severe headache, and, while 
attacked by no proper cerebral symptoms, noticed diplopia, which 
afterwards became more marked. 

The question first arises as to whether any proper connection is 
to be established between the two paralytic affections, the loss of 
power in the right tractus opticus and the right abducens. We are 
of the opinion that this must be answered in the negative, for the 
following reasons : — 

(1.) The hemiopia is evidently to be traced to the results of apo- 
plexy in the right hemisphere. Its sudden approach, attended by 
cerebral symptoms and succeeded by this particular affection of 
vision and hemiplegia of the left side, admits of no other inference. 


From such an apoplectic source on the right side the paralysis of 
the right abducens could not evidently proceed, but must be referred 
to a second effusion on the left side, if connected with any central 
apoplectic source. 

(2.) Supposing any connection to exist between the two affections, 
as, for example, that a basilar process supervened on the preexist- 
ing cerebral disease of the right side, it would seem remarkable 
that the sharply-defined traces of the previous attack underwent ab- 
solutely no variation, but remained entirely as before. It may be 
added in this connection that the slight lameness of the left foot, a 
relic of that attack, has not experienced the slightest modification 
from the late event. 

(3.) It is within the bounds of belief that a circumscribed apo- 
plectic effusion intra-cerebrum should give rise to no other symptoms 
of paralysis than a loss of power in the abducens of the opposite side, 
as has been seen in cases of facial paralysis ; still this isolated action, 
with no concurrent cerebral symptoms, is in any case improbable. The 
paralysis of the abducens itself, although not entire, is still very 
characteristic ; consequently if the seat of the cause of the affection 
were central, we should expect it to cover some ground and cerebral 
symptoms to coexist during the period of development. 

(4.) An analysis of the case shows the affection to have occurred 
under circumstances favorable to, and to have developed in the man- 
ner of, an abducens paralysis proceeding from external causes. 

For these reasons we believe ourselves compelled to regard this 
recent paralysis of the abducens as of rheumatic origin. Having 
distinguished between this and the remaining features of the case, 
let us return to an investigation of the amblyopia. 

The ophthalmoscope reveals a senile, ring-shaped atrophy of the 
choroid around the optic nerve, and besides this a partial, shallow 
excavation of the papilla, which is not to be regarded as of previ- 
ous existence (physiological) ; for in the first place the records, 
dated at the time of the convalescence of the patient from his apo- 
plectic attack, mention a normal state of the papilla ; secondly, the 
situation of the excavation itself within the papilla is very peculiar. 
On the right eye, indeed, its place is outwards from the point of exit 
of the central vessels, extending, however, to the outer edge of the 
papilla. In the left eye it dips along the inner edge of the papilla, 
and extends but a short distance beyond the point of exit of the 


central vessels, so that the surface of almost the entire outer half 
lies in the same plane with the contiguous retina. Its condition in 
this eye, therefore, differs materially from that of a physiological 
excavation. The state of the case admits of no doubt if we employ 
a largely-magnified inverted image and notice the effect of moving 
the convex glass.* The edges of the excavation having been once 
found, it may also be made out by the increase of whiteness the part 
has acquired through the greater prominence of the lamina cribrosa. 
Inasmuch as the right half of each papilla is affected by atrophic 
excavation, we have to do with a disappearance of nerve-fibres cor- 
responding with the direction of the hemiopia. I lay the more stress 
on this result because, with the utmost watchfulness, I never before 
succeeded, in a case of cerebral hemiopia, in discovering such a 
change capable of being assigned to one half of the optic nerve. 
It may be because this occurs so gradually that the proper cases 
were not observed for a suitable length of time. As has been al- 
ready stated, up to the close of the previous record, which was 
taken nearly five months after the apoplectic attack, such a discovery 
had not been made in the case of our own patient. 

The greatest doubt still prevails as to the position in the trunk of the optic nerve 
of the fibres pertaining respectively to the fasciculus lateralis and cruciatus. I have 
established, I think, beyond all doubt, the old theory of semi-decussation by the 
accumulation of exact pathological proof; still it is not yet possible to form a correct 
conception of the anatomical situation. If, in a case of perfectly shavply-defined 
hemiopia occurring on corresponding sides, the vertical boundary line of the de- 
fective portion did not pass through the point of fixation, but rather through the 
middle of the "blind spot,"t we should have simply to suppose that the fibres 
situated in the outer half of the optic nerve (which radiate outwards on the 
retina) belong to the lateral line, those radiating inwards, on the other 
hand, to the fasciculus cruciatus. Such a disposition of things, however, 
would hardly conform with the functional needs, for then the collective im- 
pressions originating in the macula lutea would be transmitted to the cor- 

* It is hardly necessary to state that this allusion refers to the well-known fact that in 
cases of excavation a peculiar ophthalmoscopic effect is produced by using the inverted 
image and slightly moving the convex object lens laterally or vertically, keeping always the 
same distance from the observed eye. The edges of the excavation are seen to move in a 
different plane from its base, seeming to slide over it. This effect is naturally more marked 

with an object-glass of comparatively long focal distance, 3 i or even J. It is strange that 
no allusion is made to the binocular ophthalmoscope, the use of which throws this method 
completely in the shade.— Translator. 

f Corresponding, of course, in a projected field of vision to the position of the optic-nerve 
entrance. — Translator. 


responding cerebral hemisphere (through the fasciculus lateralis), and we 
should have to sacrifice the main point in the theory of semi-decussation, ac- 
cording to which the impressions made on identical retinal points are brought 
together in one tractus opticus, and thus to a centre in one cerebral hemisphere. 
The fact, that in cases of cerebral hemiopia the line of division passes through 
the point of fixation, requires a portion of the fibres belonging to the fasciculus 
cruciatus to radiate outwards from the papilla ; in other words, to be already situ- 
ated in its temporal half. It is not, therefore, in cases of atrophy of the fascicu- 
lus cruciatus, to be expected that the atrophy should be strictly confined to the 
inner half of the optic nerve ; while, on the other hand, the paralysis of the fas- 
ciculus lateralis cannot involve the entire outer half (reckoning from the point of 
exit of the vessels). On the whole, however, these collections of fibres make up 
the bulk of the respective halves of the papilla, and in a case of permanent 
cerebral hemiopia such a state of the papilla as the present would seem very 

The prognosis of the case may be given as favorable, as far as 
regards the danger of blindness. Even were the apoplectic affec- 
tion of one side, which has lasted so long, to advance, it would only, in 
accordance with our theory, cause the hemiopia to become more 
strongly marked ; could not, however, lead to an invasion beyond 
the vertical line of equal division, or even to a permanent and con- 
siderable failure of acuteness of vision. Entire blindness can su- 
pervene on a one-sided apoplectic affection only (a) when an apo- 
plectic affection developes itself in the other hemisphere; (b) when 
fresh effusions into the hemisphere originally affected cause general 
cerebral derangement, perhaps through anaemia ; (c) when a basilar 
disease, directly affecting the trunks of the optic nerves, supervenes ; 
(d) when a limitation of space in the cranium involves compression 
of the cavernous sinus, and, in consequence, venous strangulation of 
the papilla; (e) when the continued progress of the encephalo- 
meningitic disease causes a secondary neuritis. All these possibili- 
ties have but little to do with our case. Considering the diseased 
state of his vascular system, the patient might, to be sure, be seized 
with an apoplectic effusion in the left hemisphere ; such an affection, 
however, would specially involve the left optic-nerve centre. A fresh 
and violent effusion on the right side, causing symptoms of general 
cerebral disease, would either prove fatal or else diminish sufficient- 
ly to allow the connection with the left optic-nerve centre to be 
reestablished. The purely apoplectic nature of the affection and 
the absence of all symptoms of implication of the meninges give us 
at present no reason to suppose any probability of a basilar process. 
Increase of intra-cranial pressure takes place only in the incipient 


stage of apoplexy ; hence venous strangulation of the papilla, an 
effect arising only from the prolonged action of such a cause, is not 
to be seen here, but is especially common with tumors. Derived 
neuritis (neuritis descendens) finally seems to occur in apoplectic 
effusions only when reactive prodromal symptoms of a positive cha- 
racter have gained considerably in intensity and extent in the adja- 
cent portion of the cerebrum. In the case of a person who has 
extensive arterial ossification affecting the action of the heart, and 
who has already been the subject of an apoplectic effusion, it is of 
course impossible to foresee the form that later attacks of the same 
or other affections of the brain may take j this much, however, is 
certain, viz., that the disease must entirely change its habitation or 
its shape to produce blindness. A change for the worse (i. e., a 
more strongly-marked state of the hemiopia) might result from the 
occurrence of fresh effusions in the right hemisphere, or more exten- 
sive changes in the cerebral substance about the previous deposit ; 
still, considering that the condition of things has for three years 
been entirely the same, such apprehensions are of minor consequence. 
On the other hand, recovery — in other words, restoration of the 
field of vision — is by no means to be expected. The long duration 
of this condition of things, and the partial atrophic excavation of 
the papilla, forbid such a hope. 

Be it said in this connection that the resulting on similar sides (i. e., on the 
left or right side) of limitations of the field of vision or impairments of eccentric 
vision is very frequent in cases of apoplexy, and that the friends of the patient 
notice his inability to direct his movements on one side — as, for example, in the 
taking of things at table. Central vision suffers commonly but little, when 
the general derangements caused during the period of development are once over, 
this being equally true of cases of complete cerebral hemiopia, extending to the 
vertical line of equal division. This latter affection is much more troublesome 
for scholars when it affects the left tractus opticus rather than the right. For in 
the first case one loses the eccentric impression of what follows,* so essential to 
rapid reading, while in the latter it only becomes a little harder to catch a new 
line after having completed its predecessor. 

As regards the treatment, there is nothing to be added. No agent 
could affect the apoplectic residuum, and we have, therefore, only to 

* In the German, " excentrisches Vorauslesen." In reading one word on a page, the main 
sense of the words immediately succeeding is insensibly perceived, although attention be not 
voluntarily directed to them. The macula lutea takes cognizance of each successive word, 
and the lateral portions of the retina simultaneously observe what follows. An exact equiva- 
lent of the German phrase it is hard to find. — Translator. 



counsel an anti-apoplectic manner of life and avoidance of well- 
known predisposing causes. 

In a few weeks the patient was again presented. The paralysis 
of the right abducens and the consequent diplopia had disappeared 
under a rather inactive treatment, which fact certainly goes to con- 
firm the theory of a rheumatic paralysis ; the derangement of vision 
was of course the same. 

Case V. 
Progressive Amaurosis, coming on under the form of a Central Sco- 
toma, with a simultaneous Anomaly of the Periphery of the Field oj 

August N., 23 years old, a robust-looking countryman, presents 
himself on account of a derangement of vision, which was first no- 
ticed in the left eye six months ago, shortly afterwards appeared in 
the right, and since that time has steadily progressed. We find in 
the left eye a large central scotoma, with an angle of aperture of 
about 20 Q , within which only bare perception of light exists. Close 
to the temporal edge of this scotoma the eccentric acuteness of vision 
is most developed, and diminishes then (the position of the " blind 
spot " being but a short distance removed from this point) in a 
nearly normal manner up to the periphery of the field, the sweep of 
which in the temporal direction is normal. Beyond the nasal edge 
of the scotoma the field of vision, examined by daylight, seems cer- 
tainly normal; by subdued lamplight, however, a well-marked indis- 
tinctness of the eccentric vision is found to extend to the border of 
the field, which in this direction is appreciably contracted. Nearly 
the same state of things obtains upwards, while below the field of 
vision beyond the scotoma is tolerably normal. The state of the 
right eye is nearly the same, except only that the scotoma and the 
anomaly of the field of vision are somewhat less marked inwards and 
upwards. The patient employs in each eye eccentric fixation, bring- 
ing to bear on the object the portion of the retina situated between 
the fovea centralis and the temporal edge of the optic nerve, as pos- 
sessing the best lateral vision. He can thus count fingers, with one 
eye in 6', with the other in 8', and with the right can, moreover, de- 
cipher the largest letters of the test. During the whole period of 
development of the disease, and even earlier, the patient has suffer- 
ed from persistent headache, with a feeling of heaviness, a sense of 


confusion and occasional giddiness, very marked drowsiness, and 
in former years from frequent epistaxis; the frontal region, too, on 
being tapped manifests sensitiveness. In the physical condition 
otherwise, and the habits of life, nothing of moment is dis- 

The complexion of the case as regards the prognosis is entirely 
different from that of Case III., where a central scotoma also ex- 
isted. Our prognosis there was favorable, as far as the danger of 
blindness was concerned, for the reason that the periphery of the 
field of vision was entirely normal. But in this case there is, in 
addition to the scotoma, a considerable contraction of the field of 
vision upwards and inwards, also an indistinctness of eccentric 
vision in the same directions. It is this additional fact that causes 
us to suspect progressive blindness in these cases of central or 
eccentric interruptions of the field, although with them genuine 
atrophy seems to be less frequently involved than in the ordinary 
cases where contractions of the field of vision are alone found 
(Case II.). In such cases of blindness commencing with scotoma, 
I have several times had occasion to observe alterations of the 
cerebral substance following hyperemia of long duration, and even 
numerous latent traces of encephalitis. In spite of the bad prog, 
nosis we associate with the existence of contraction of the field of 
vision, we will not refer as unreservedly to the necessary approach 
of blindness as in a case of genuine atrophy (Case II.), for we have 
in fact here decided symptoms of cerebral congestion, and it is not 
beyond the bounds of possibility that treatment addressed to 
them might bring the loss of sight to a stand-still. The patient 
states that a brother somewhat younger than himself was attacked 
a few years ago with cerebral symptoms and loss of vision similar 
to his own, got worse for six months, lost the ability to read, 
but since that time had remained about the same. 

As regards the diagnosis, the persistent congestive headache, 
especially the local sensitiveness of the cranium, would tend to 
make us infer the existence of an inflammatory affection, perhaps 
a chronic meningitis with cerebral hyperemia, or even an insidious 
encephalitis. The symptoms, however, do not justify us in pro. 
nouncing a decided opinion. — The present treatment will be that 
of chronic meningitis, a " milk-cure," leeches behind the ears, by 
and bye a seton, and sublimate internally. 


This treatment was followed up for several months (Iodide of 
potash, the decoction of Zittmann and the " cold-water cure " being 
subsequently employed). The cerebral symptoms disappeared almost 
entirely, the loss of vision, however, seemed to remain stationary 
for a time, and then slowly progressed. At the time of the pa- 
tient's dismissal a small streak of the field of vision still existed, in- 
wards from the central scotoma, leading us to infer that the defec- 
tive portion at the periphery will speedily be merged in the central 
portion where vision has failed. In a dim light the patient's move- 
ments were already very uncertain. An entirely unfavorable prog- 
nosis must therefore be given. 

Meanwhile, an examination of the brother of the patient having 
been made, it was ascertained that while the cerebral symptoms at 
the commencement of the disease bore the same stamp as in our 
own case, the physical signs had assumed a different form. The 
confines of the field of vision had remained entirely normal ; the 
acuteness of vision is now reduced to about T \, owing to an 
ill-defined central scotoma with an angle of aperture of from 6° to 
8° j there is also a moderate amount of atrophic degeneration of 
the papilla, This state of things has lasted in the present case 
about four years, and has not yielded to the various remedial 
measures that have been meanwhile employed. It comes under the 
head of Case III. Probably both brothers were affected by the 
same original cause, acting however to a different degree, and ex- 
erting consequently a different effect. It has previously been 
observed that even the benign forms of amblyopia arising from 
causes connected with the circulation (for example amblyopia 
potatorum), pass into a form of amaurosis if the cause become 
more active; and it is especially probable that permanent central 
scotoma, in the course of which is developed a partial atrophy of 
the optic nerve, visible on the papilla, needs only the more vigor- 
ous action of the same cause to produce progressive atrophy. This 
undeniable connection of cause should not of course prevent us 
from making a distinction as regards symptoms in forms of disease 
the prognosis of which may be widely different. — I have observed 
hereditary transmission, the possibility of which we cannot deny, 
less frequently in genuine atrophy than in cases of congestive 
amblyopia, where the field of vision is either normal or where cen- 
tral interruptions exist; a fact which need not surprise us when we 
consider the frequent inheritance of a congestive tendency. 


Case VI. 

Blindness of each Eye of sudden occurrence, with incomplete Restoration 

of Vision on one side, 'probably caused by a Basilar Tumor. 

Friedrich R., a tailor, 32 years old, pale and bearing evidence of 
insufficient nourishment, comes to consult us for a recent loss of 
vision of the right eye and weakness of the left. The functional 
examination reveals the absence of quantitative perception of light 
on the right side, diminution of the acuteness of vision to £ on the 
left, and (by lamplight) indistinctness of eccentric vision in the 
outer and lower quadrant of the field. The pupil of the blind right 
eye is entirely insensible to the influx of light ; contracts energeti- 
cally, however, when the left eye is illuminated, a circumstance which 
excludes any suspicion of simulation. The optic papilla of each 
side, as well as the size of the retinal vessels, is entirely normal. 
The history of the case reveals the fact that the patient during the 
last few years had had several severe attacks of vertigo, which had 
twice been so intense as to cause loss of consciousness, and once 
had induced a temporary weakness of the left arm. The mind re- 
mained unaffected, headache occurred only from time to time and 
very lightly, and the cranium was in no part sensitive. The eyes 
had been entirely unaffected up to within fourteen days ; one morn- 
ing, however, the patient, while at his work, observed a limitation of 
the right field of vision, objects far removed to one side seeming 
entirely to disappear. This obscuration advanced from the tempo- 
ral side inwards with much regularity, so that on the third day ob- 
jects at which the right eye was directed seemed situated at the 
edge of the defective portion. On the sixth day only a faint glim- 
mer of light existed on the nasal side. The day afterwards all 
perception of light had disappeared. It is only a few days since a 
decrease in the acuteness of vision of the left eye has been observed, 
and with this is particularly connected a great sensitiveness to light, 
indicated by the, so to speak, dazzled manner of the patient. 

The method of development of the blindness in the right eye has 
been emphatically unusual. It differs in its rapid course (in all, six 
days) from the amaurosis dependent on atrophy of the optic nerve; 
on the other hand, from anaesthesia of the retina (Case VII.) — to 
which otherwise the sensitive condition of the patient offers a strong 
provocation — in the steady advance of the failure in the field of 


vision, so appreciable to the patient. The measured advance of the 
contraction of the field of vision naturally gives rise to the supposi- 
tion of a material agency at work on the trunk of the optic nerve, 
spreading gradually from the inner to the outer fibres, and inasmuch 
as a similar effect begins to be produced on the second eye, and no 
symptoms of a diffused cerebral affection or one existing on both 
sides are apparent, we must locate this agency at the base of the 
cranium. The previous attacks that the patient has had are in per- 
fect harmony with the theory of a basilar neoplasma. If the de- 
velopment of such a formation be slow, there may be circumstances 
under which the adjacent nerves and the cerebrum itself may become 
adapted to it, allowing of its remaining entirely latent. Compres- 
sion of the basilar vessels and the derangements of cerebral circu- 
lation dependent thereon— for example, faint-like or epileptiform 
attacks, with, perhaps, interruption of the arterial circulation and 
transient hemiplegia— occur then only periodically and under the 
additional influence of accidental causes, and the whole aspect of 
the disease may for a long time be confined to these symptoms. 
Paralysis of the cerebral nerves takes place when either the morbid 
growth, as such, cuts off the nerves, or when the nerve connective- 
tissue undergoes an irritative process, or when too great an amount 
of pressure gives rise to compression of the nutrient vessels, and 
thereby to a loss of nerve-substance. One of these processes must 
have recently allied itself to the existing difficulty and have affected 
the optic nerves. The normal condition of all the other nerves, 
especially of the branches of the oculomotorius, warrants us in 
placing the morbid growth in front of the chiasma and between the 
optic-nerve trunks, from which focus its action would first be appa- 
rent on the crucial fibres (inner retinal portion). Considering, 
however, the deficient character of the symptoms, the theory of such 
a new growth may be set down as the more probable diagnosis. 
We meet with cases of defined basilar periostitis which, contrary to 
all expectation, induce no pain, and where the extremely gradual 
development of the symptoms simulates the progress of a tumor. 
Finally, there are forms of paralysis which seem to abundantly sup- 
port the theory of a basilar tumor, but where there is an absolute 
failure of anatomical confirmation. More prolonged observation 
will, perhaps, invest such a supposition with increased certainty. 
AVe must give a prognosis unfavorable, to be sure, but not as de- 


tided, as regards the vision, as we should in ordinary atrophy. The 
more the case differs in its aspect from those of frequent occurrence 
and subjected to the light of abundant experience, the more cautious 
must we be in our prognostic utterances. If the cause be really a 
tumor, the final result must be fatal, but a partial restoration of 
vision is by no means impossible, considering the short duration of 
the blindness. This would only be the fact in a case where the 
tumor has really cut off the optic nerve. If the loss of conductive 
power in the nerves is attributable to inflammatory action in the 
connective tissue or compression of the nutrient vessels, the pro- 
cesses may be partially transitory and give way to some amount of 
change. Thus in the case of tumors, in spite of their constant in- 
crease, we not infrequently observe an amelioration in certain classes 
of paralytic symptoms.* For the present it is natural to suppose 
that the limitation of the left field of vision will continue to pro- 
gressively develope; the result must show, however, whether it will 
lead to entire loss of sight in this eye or only to temporal hemiopia. 
The patient was again presented, eight days after his admission ; 
the contraction of the left field of vision had meanwhile become more 
and more extended, following much the same course as did the right, 
and within a day the patient had been deprived of all perception of 
light in this second eye, too, becoming, consequently, stone-blind. 
Moreover, of late, a progressive failure of the sense of smell had 
taken place, not amounting, however, to complete loss of smell. 
An ophthalmoscopic examination gives a negative result with regard 
to the papilla. In the interval a slight attack of faintness had been 

The patient remained six days in this state of complete blindness, 
at the end of which time some perception of light began to manifest 
itself in the left eye, as well as a gradual restoration of the left field 
of vision, beginning on the nasal side. Six weeks after the case 
was first presented, the field of vision of this eye had attained a 
nearly normal development ; the acuteness of vision, however, had 
only reached T \y, and eccentric vision in the neighborhood of the 
temporal edge remained indistinct. This improvement and simul- 
taneous increase of the sense of smell followed the administration 
of the lactate of zinc in increasing doses ; was probably, however, 

* See the instructive case published by Samisch in the February number of this year's maga- 
zine, pp. 51-55. 


not connected with this agent, to which, in cases of idiopathic reti- 
nal hyperesthesia (see Case VII.) I am highly partial. The right 
eye remains entirely blind, and its papilla now offers clear evidence 
of atrophic degeneration. 

The last recorded condition of things seems now (a month later) 
to remain unaltered. That the partial restoration of vision on the 
left side by no means detracts from our original diagnostic supposi- 
tion of a basilar neoplasma, has already been settled. The patient, 
too, continues pale and exceedingly decrepid ; the left papilla, in its 
turn, commences gradually to exhibit traces of atrophic degenera- 
tion, without, however, any reduction in the partially-recovered 

Case VII. 

Anesthesia of the Retina, with Concentric Limitation of the Field of 

Vision ; Quick Recovery. 

Carl S., a delicate boy, 10 years of age, is brought to the clinique 
for deranged vision of the right eye and twitching of the face. The 
right eye is extremely intolerant of light, it being hardly in his 
power to hold it open when exposed to strong daylight ; on soften- 
ing the light, however, and neutralizing a hyperopia^, the acuteness 
of vision is found to be £; the field of vision is concentrically, 
though irregularly limited, rather more downwards than in any 
other direction. Its angle of aperture in the vertical direction 
is about 40° ; in the horizontal, 50°- By lamplight, even though 
limited in amount, no diminution in this diameter of the field of 
vision is noticed ; in fact, it rather increases, and this, too, is the 
case when the patient is made to look by daylight through dark-blue 
glasses (shade No. 8). In every direction phosphenes are producible. 
It is particularly striking that pressure behind the upper part of the 
ora serrata at once brings out the lower phosphene, although the 
transmission of impressions is most deranged in this direction. The 
phosphene in question is projected at least thirty degrees below the 
edge of the contracted field of vision. The result of the ophthal- 
moscopic examination is entirely negative. The acuteness and field 
of vision of the left eye are normal. On the right half of the face 
periodic twitchings of separate muscles occur, particularly of the 
zygomatici and levatores ; which increase, it is true, when the admis- 
sion of bright light causes the right eye to be closed, but last even 


when it is entirely shaded. The interval between their occurrence 
is seldom more than half a minute, the twitchings themselves being 
slight and lasting only a few seconds. 

With the exception of some nervous irritability, the patient's 
health was always good. Three weeks before he presented himself 
he was, while walking in the country, caught in a thunder storm, 
and much frightened at a tree, a short distance from him, being 
struck by lightning. The next morning, the derangement of vision 
and the twitchings were both observed. 

The presentation of these particulars was coupled with the fol- 
lowing remarks : — We have here such a case of partial anaesthesia 
of the retina, especially of its peripheric zone, as often occurs in 
excitable children and nervous or hysterical women, and inspires 
even experienced ophthalmic surgeons with an erroneous fear of 
progressive amaurosis. The particular cause seems peculiar in such 
cases • it is, however, probable that we have here simply to regard 
the accompanying mental impression. Such forms of anaesthesia, 
coupled sometimes with a loss of cutaneous sensibility to pain, or, 
as in the present instance, with twitchings, may be seen to particu- 
larly occur in those cases where general excitability has acted as 
the predisposing mental agitation, as the immediate cause. They 
therefore particularly affect individuals of excitable temperament, 
the subjects of anaemia, those convalescing from severe diseases — 
for example, children getting over scarlet fever, measles and ty- 
phoid, whose power of resistance has not yet become developed. 
In comparing the characteristic signs in these cases with those in 
amaurotic affections, we shall find the former as follows : — 

(1.) Only a slight diminution of the central acuteness of vision 
seldom passing the bounds of £ or |, while there exists an impor- 
tant anomaly in the confines of the field of vision, generally consist- 
ing in concentric, irregular limitation. 

(2.) A development either sudden or reaching its acme in a few 
hours or days. 

(3.) Retention of the phosphenes at points corresponding to these 
portions of the retiria where there is no perception of light, show- 
ing a loss of connection between the rods and fibres, dependent on 
a local cause. 

(4.) Simultaneous hyperesthesia of the retina and the active 
character of the retinal difficulty thereon dependent, in consequence 


of which vision either remains as good or improves on using dark- 
blue glasses or in a dim light, circumstances which in general cause 
a diminution of vision. 

(5.) The age and sex of the patient. It is well known that the 
amaurotic affections dependent on atrophy of the optic nerve — leav- 
ing out of the question congenital states as well as further intracra- 
nial derangements, manifesting their existence by palpable symptoms — 
very seldom occur with children and, in the case of adults, are 
infinitely more frequent with men than women. In this form of 
retinal anaesthesia the opposite is the case. According to my 
observations it affects almost exclusively women and children, and 
in the exceptional cases where men were seized — a thing that has 
happened only twice in my experience — the subjects were those 
where temperament and bodily constitution approached either the 
feminine type or that of the child. 

Finally the predisposing and accompanying circumstances are of 
importance, because under the first head we mostly meet with mental 
impressions, under the second with a loss of cutaneous sensibility 
and local affections of the motory system. In our own case a pre- 
liminary examination of the sensitiveness of the skin has given only 
a negative result. On the other hand the peculiar facial affection is 
completely characteristic. 

As a whole these points of differential diagnosis are not without 
value, though taken separately the departures from them may be 
numerous. And first we have those exceptional cases in which 
(contrary to No. 1) the acuteness as well as field of vision suffers an 
unusual diminution. I can on this occasion refer to two in which 
blindness had nearly been produced. An unfavorable prognosis 
might have beeri given, still the other symptoms seemed to justify 
me in speaking encouragingly, and the usual treatment was followed 
by entire recovery. It is possible that certain cases of sudden and 
entire blindness might also be included in this category ; it is not, 
however, in our power to establish rules of differential diagnosis 
between them and other incurable forms. 

In the case of a boy 8 years of age a very remarkable phenomenon was observ- 
ed. After a concentric limitation of the field of vision had lasted some time, 
and all other symptoms had decidedly indicated that the case belonged to the 
foregoing category, the hyperesthesia of the retina very much increased, and the 
next day there took place entire restoration of the periphery of the field of 
vision, accompanied, however, in each eye by a large central scotoma, diminishing 


the acuteness of vision from I to ^ (eccentric). This turn so surprised me that I 
at first refused credence to the statement, until over-persuaded by measuring the 
scotoma at various distances and by following up the case. The boy was con- 
valescent from the measles, always delicate and possessed much nervous excita- 
bility ; the usual treatment brought about his cure. 

The amount, too, of the accompanying retinal hyperesthesia varies 
extremely, being often extremely marked in the case of hysterical 
patients, while children between 6 and 14 years of age, the most 
frequent subjects of the disease, may have only a moderate feeling 
of being dazzled. The affection of one side only makes the above- 
cited case exceptional ; the disease almost always occurs on both 
sides, though it may be to a different extent. The fact that in cases 
of recent occurrence the optic papilla retains its normal appearance 
is of course of no value as regards the differential diagnosis, inas- 
much as this is also applicable to cases of a serious nature that have 
existed but a short time (Case YL). On the other hand it is remarka- 
ble that even where the difficulty has existed some time and not 
been treated, the papilla may retain its normal redness, transparency 
and superficies. 

Tt follows from what has been said that we hold the prognosis in 
these cases of retinal anaesthesia to be favorable. An entire cure 
is generally effected within a few weeks ; occasionally the disease 
remains for some time at a certain height till the advent of con- 
valescence, and only in a few cases have I observed the care not- 
withstanding a long delay to be incomplete, owing to the but partial 
disappearance of the peripheric contraction of the field of vision 
and of the hyperesthesia — of the last, especially, where (as in cases 
of hysteria) the general health could not be established on a firm 
foundation. I have never observed these cases to result in amauro- 
tic blindness. 

As regards the question of treatment much stress is first of all 
to be laid on the regulation of the allowance of light. The good 
results that have been said to follow the entire and methodic depriva- 
tion of light in amaurotic affections may, I think, be attributed to 
the fact that the cases were either those in point or else of the 
nature of hemeralopia, a state in many respects analogous, different 
though it be with regard to the retinal torpor. In progressive 
atrophy the light, it is true, should be softened in order to remove a 
cause that may accelerate blindness; this is, however, never observ- 
ed to produce a remarkably curative effect. It is. my custom to first 


keep those affected with anaesthesia of the retina for several days in ' 
a completely darkened chamber, and then, during perhaps 6 or 8 
days, to allow a gradual increase in the amount of light. Later, 
when the patients are allowed to go out, blue glasses of different 
shades, varying according to the degree of light they are exposed 
to, are to be given them. The importance of this portion of the 
treatment varies directly with the amount of retinal hyperesthesia. 

Among medicinal agents I place my chief reliance on the internal 
administration of the preparations of zinc in increasing doses, fol- 
lowing the method recommended by Jaksch in the treatment of a 
loss of cutaneous sensibility. I formerly frequently employed tartar 
emetic in nauseating doses, and generally obtained a satisfactory 
result ; this plan, however, is far more disagreeable to the patient 
than the treatment by zinc, and where the digestion is affected can- 
not be used indiscriminately ; I therefore counsel that it be had 
recourse to only when the use of zinc has failed to produce an im- 
pression. If improvement has once commenced, I go over to mild 
tonics, administer iron, give aromatic and salt baths and cold spong- 
ing. All this treatment must have reference to the state of the 
general health in the case before us. It is indubitable that a well- 
balanced mind exercises a decided influence. As the passions often 
furnish the exciting cause, so have I seen their indulgence followed 
by a relapse in many cases where a cure was already in progress. 
Setting the patient at ease as to the true nature of the affection, 
often brings about the favorable crisis. During treatment the exer- 
cise of the accommodation must be entirely forbidden ; on the other 
hand when the dark chamber can once be dispensed with, much time 
should be spent in the open air. In this form of disease I must 
caution against the abstraction of blood, as well as all remedies 
which reduce the system, excite the nerves or interrupt sleep. Their 
employment is not only followed by an immediate change for the 
worse, but the disease developes a more obstinate character. 

The boy was subjected to such a course of treatment, the light 
being regulated and zinc administered (lactate of zinc, at first gr. 
iss., afterwards gr. v. a day). Twelve days after his admission the 
twitchings of the right half of the face had been reduced to a mini- 
mum, the acuteness of vision had increased to more than §. Tbe 
limitation of the field of vision outwards, inwards, and upwards 
had disappeared, and was only perceptible downwards ; the retinal 


hyperesthesia had diminished, but was not entirely obviated. The 
patient was now ordered iron and cold spongings, and, when next 
shown at the clinique, the ability to use the eyes freely and a resti- 
tutio ad integrum were demonstrated, the cure having taken in all 
four weeks. 

Case VIII. 
Temporal Hemiopia, following a Basilar Affection (supposed Perios- 
titis) ; Dubious Prognosis ; Recovery. 

Mrs. Emily B., 36 years of age, presents herself at the clinique 
on account of an impairment of vision that has lasted only eight 
days. On examination, there is found in each eye acuteness of 
vision of only }, as also an entirely symmetrical defect in each tem- 
poral half of the field of vision. All perception of light is 
lost over the space extending outwards from a line going nearly 
through the middle of the " blind spot," while over the space be- 
tween such a line and a vertical one passing through the point of 
fixation, perception is so imperfect that fingers can be counted only 
in the immediate vicinity of the latter. On the nasal half of the 
field, on the contrary, eccentric vision is everywhere normal, even by 
reduced lamplight. In conformity to this the temporal phosphene 
is entirely wanting, while the nasal is produced with great ease and 
distinctness. The ophthalmoscopic examination gives an entirely 
negative result. As regards the antecedents and the mode of deve- 
lopment, the following is obtained : the previous health of the pa- 
tient had always been good, and no trace of syphilis had ever exist- 
ed; but several months after her last (seventh) delivery she had 
been seized with headache of extraordinary severity, and at the 
same time with diplopia. She had been at the clinique for this half 
a year before her present visit, and at that time the cause of the 
diplopia was found to be a paralysis of the right abducens, the 
functional state of the retina itself seeming to be entirely normal. 
The cause of the paralysis, as well as of the headache, we supposed 
to be akin to periostitis (basilar). The headache entirely yielded 
at that time to a derivative course of treatment, but the paralysis of 
the abducens proved excessively obstinate, so that after iodide of 
potash had been given for several months and electricity tried, a loss 
of mobility to the extent of more than 1|"' remained almost sta- 
tionary, and the consequent confusion of vision (contraction of the 


internus having resulted) had to be relieved by setting back the in- 
sertion of the left rectus internus. From that time up to within 
eight days of the present visit the patient had been perfectly well ; the 
catamenia had, however, failed to appear at the last two periods, 
and she was then attacked by heavy and violent pains extending 
over the entire head, as well as by the derangement of vision already 
referred to, which continued steadily to increase. 

No particular result is obtained from a general physical examina- 
tion. The patient is free from fever, but has a worn look, attributa- 
ble, no doubt, to the loss of sleep caused by the pains in the head. 
Neither is anything definite discovered by the exploration of the 
orbits ; each bulbus allows itself to be pressed against the cushion 
of fat without thereby exhibiting any signs of sensitiveness. On 
the other hand the skull, particularly on the level of the basis cranii, 
is exceedingly sensitive to tapping, the most pain being caused when 
two points, situated opposite each other, are simultaneously tapped. 

It is clear that the reason of the present derangement of vision 
must be located at the basis cranii. No change that could account 
for the limitation of the field of vision is to be met with in the eye ; 
such cases of temporal hemiopia being in general hardly ever depen- 
dent on intra-ocular complication. An orbital cause might certainly 
exert an influence on the nasal portion of the optic nerve; still, 
leaving out of account the fact that such a cause must be symmetri- 
cal and affect both sides, there exists no sort of basis for such a 
supposition. On the other hand, the localization of the difficulty at 
the middle of the basis cranii satisfactorily explains all the symptoms. 
We know that a cause of disease which has its seat here and acts 
upon the optic nerves, first affects the fasciculi cruciati, and thus in- 
volves the connection with the temporal border of the field of vision. 
If the action extend equally on the two sides, the temporal limita- 
tion of the field of vision will be symmetrical. We never in these 
cases find the defective portion standing out in such sharp relief 
against the part that retains its normal functions as in hemiopia on 
similar sides. This is, a priori, comprehensible. When one tractus 
opticus is paralyzed, perhaps from a loss of cerebral connection, the 
boundary of the perceptive portion becomes sharply defined, corres- 
ponding to the distribution of fibres of this tractus on the retina, 
and following the example of what occurs in paralysis of the trige- 
minus, in the median line of the face. If, on the contrary, the two 


optic tracts feel the influence of a morbid cause having its seat at 
the middle of the basis cranii — an irritated state, for example, of 
the connective tissue, proceeding from the periosteum — it would be 
hard to understand how the action thereon dependent should expend 
its full intensity on certain bundles of fibres without to some extent 
implicating those adjoining. We therefore find under all circum- 
stances in cases of temporal hemiopia, an intermediate region* in 
the field of vision. The case of the patient now introduced com- 
pletely harmonizes with this view — the field of vision, as already 
stated, failing entirely beyond the "blind spot," while between the 
u blind spot " and point of fixation a gradual increase of sensitive- 
ness to impressions takes place. The theory of a basilar origin 
finds further support in the nature of the pains in the head and the 
increase in them caused by tapping the head in the region of the 
basis cranii, a symptom which, though wanting in many cases of 
basilar disease, is certainly not without significance when present. 
A similar meaning is to be ascribed to the nature of the affection 
passed through six months ago. Besides intense and general headache, 
it was characterized by the particular obstinacy of the accompanying 
paralysis of the abducens. Experience teaches us that the ordinary, 
so-called rheumatic paralysis of the abducens may be accompanied 
at the time of its development by local pains in the forehead and 
temples, but not by general and severe headache ; moreover, when 
once the greater part of the power of motion has been restored, 
such cases of paralysis generally recover more uniformly and com- 
pletely than was the case here. Finally, if the location of the diffi- 
culty within the cavity of the cranium be once allowed, the theory 
of a basilar origin receives support from the fact that there is not 
the slightest reason for supposing it to be in the cerebrum. In spite 
of the pronounced paralysis, formerly of the abducens and now of 
the crucial fibres of the optic nerves, there have been neither hemi- 
plegic attacks, mental derangement, nor affections of the head of 
any kind to indicate a disease of the cerebral substance. 

* Vebergangsbezirk. No analogous terms exist in the English language for many similar 
expressions. "We are here to understand that the portions of the retina respectively des- 
titute of vision, and which retain their normal powers, are not sharply separated from each 
other by a defined boundary, but slowly merge, the one into the other, over a region 
which if the term be literally translated, bears the name of the " district of transition." — 


The task of deciding the nature of the basilar cause is much 
more difficult. The rapid development of the symptoms superven- 
ing on a state of perfect health, the extreme severity of the com- 
mencing headache, the entire intermission between the two attacks, 
seem at first sight to indicate an inflammatory condition rather than 
a new growth. Still, the possibility of the latter must not be en- 
tirely excluded. When tumors gradually form at the basis cranii, 
they may, as such, remain latent, and only betray their presence pe- 
riodically by taking on a state of irritation. On the other hand, it 
is the exception for new growths that have once given rise to symp- 
toms of paralysis, to allow a temporary return of an entirely normal 
condition. As a rule, we have only variations in the symptoms of 
paralysis, some taking their departure and others making their ap- 
pearance or persisting. When we are not able to form a definite 
diagnosis with certainty, and probabilities are evenly balanced, it is 
without doubt a sound, practical principle to proceed on that theory 
which seems to open to us the best field for effort. This is preemi- 
nently true when the probabilities incline in favor of that theory. 
Let us then, in the case of our patient, for the present dismiss the 
idea of a basilar neoplasma, and give our attention to the theory of 
an inflammatory affection. And this can be well located only in the 
dura mater. Inflammations of the more delicate cerebral membranes 
have too great a tendency to diffusion to cause paralytic affections 
within such narrow limits. Their development is generally rapid, 
and is accompanied by febrile and general cerebral symptoms, while 
they pass off in a different manner. The date of the first attack 
renders it, moreover, possible for us to connect the defined pachy- 
meningitis, which we feel warranted in assuming, with the puerperal 
state. We possess relatively few anatomical and clinical facts with 
regard to such defined basilar affections. I have, however, acquired 
the conviction, in which, too, the results of autopsies -have strength- 
ened me, that the most varied forms of basilar paralysis spring from 
this source. This is particularly applicable to certain forms of re- 
curring paralysis of the muscles of the eye, in fact processes of a 
periostitic nature are as a rule prone to recur. 

Our prognosis cannot be .other than doubtful. The difference in 
this respect between temporal hemiopia and that occurring on simi- 
lar sides (Case IV.) is very striking. While in the latter the continued 
action of the same morbid cause does but complete the hemiopia, 


and never causes blindness of either one or both eyes, it is of course 
possible for a source of disease situated at the base of the brain to 
exercise a constantly increasing effect on both optic nerves, overstep 
the limits of the fasciculi cruciati, and end in absolute obliteration 
of the field of vision (Case VI.). On the other hand, an entire 
pause in, or even complete disappearance of, the disease may occur 
at any stage whatsoever. This would substantially depend on the 
nature of the morbid cause. Inasmuch as in our case the supposed 
cause may disappear, and has been so short a time in force that dis- 
integration of the nervous elements is neither to be expected, nor 
visible on the papilla, recovery is possible. A more exact definition 
of our prognosis, as regards either the derangement of vision or the 
subsequent result, must naturally be based on the course of the 

The patient was first subjected to a derivative plan of treatment 
(leeches behind the ears, then dry cupping, drastic pills, derivative 
foot-baths, later iodide of potash). Under this the headache entirely 
ceased, but the field of vision remained the same, and its acuteness 
even became reduced to £. The general condition, too, excited con- 
stantly increasing fears. The urine became considerably, increased 
in quantity, and marked pallor, loss of flesh and weakness simulta- 
neously presented themselves. The daily amount of urine was from 
4000 to 6000 cubic centimetres ; its specific gravity varied between 
1002 and 1005. The color of the urine was extremely light; it 
was examined by Dr. Kiihne, and proved to contain neither sugar 
nor inosit. In the morning, thirst became unquenchable. These 
symptoms having reached their height about four weeks after her 
admission, and the bodily weight having fallen, without any increase 
of temperature, to 94 pounds, the dose of iodide of potash was re- 
duced from B i. to B ss., and liquor ferri chlorati at the same time 
ordered. A few days after this prescription, but possibly entirely 
independent of it, a diminution of the thirst and in the quantity of 
urine showed itself, shortly after which the bodily weight and vision 
commenced steadily to increase. Seven weeks after her first in- 
troduction no defect in the field of vision could be made out j the 
eccentric vision, however, in the temporal zone, particularly outwards 
and downwards, was still indistinct ; the acuteness of vision amount- 
ed to I j weight 100 pounds ; average quantity of urine in the twen- 
ty-four hours rather over 2000 cubic centimetres ; specific gravity, 


1010. Four weeks later the patient was discharged entirely conva- 
lescent; weight, 108 pounds; urine normal in amount; field of 
vision irreproachable, even by diminished light; acuteness of vision 
more than |. ; satisfactory complexion and tone. 

I would state, in conclusion, that the patient, who is a resident of 
this city, has been shown at considerable intervals, and that the last 
extract from our records, written more than a year after the de- 
rangement of vision, bears witness to an entirely normal condition 
of things. The catamenia, too, reappeared during the progress of 
the convalescence. The entire and apparently permanent recovery 
gives, we think, an increased support to our original diagnosis of a 
local basilar periostitis, although, of course, the obscurity of these 
regions leaves ample room for doubt. I was particularly interested 
in this case, partly on account of the entire disappearance of so 
marked a hemiopia, partly because the urine, in spite of its increase 
in quantity, contained neither sugar nor inosit. As regards the first, 
my experience permits me to recal but few such fortunate results ; 
the coincidence with intra-cranial processes of an increase in the 
quantity of urine has been, it is true, considerably studied ; but, as 
far as I am aware, not yet recorded in connection with such a group 
of symptoms as the present. 




Delivered Jan. 3d, 5th, 6th, 7th, 9th and 20th, 1863. 

Mrs. D., 64 years old, has a hard, ripe cataract in the right eye, an 
unripe one in the left. The external appearance of the eyes indicates 
no complication. The cataract of the left being unripe, fingers can 
be counted in 2', while the perceptive power of the right eye has 
been measured by means of our " graduated diaphragm." If we use 
an entirely darkened chamber, placing the diaphragm 8" (the distance 
which for the sake of uniformity we always employ) from the eye to 
be examined, and reduce the intensity from 100 to 1, the patient 
gives entirely correct answers till 4 is reached, but at 2 begins to be 
uncertain. This is exactly what we should expect when the cataract 
is ripe and saturated, as is here the case. If the diaphragm be set 
at 25 and moved from side to side, the patient follows it with the 
eye as accurately as could be expected, considering the diffusion of 
light. The question as to whether any considerable near-sightedness 
had previously existed, a question which — in view of the frequent 

* From a letter of von Graefe to the Editors : — 

" The case which forms the subject of this lecture is by no means an exceptional one. I 
am, however, of opinion that a description of those irregular complications that may occur 
during the healing process after flap-extraction, as well as an allusion to various points that 
are now, in this connection, receiving special attention, may be of use to the practitioner ; 
and do not hesitate, therefore, to offer some such material to the ' Klinische Monatsblattcr.' 
The most assiduous observation and the most comprehensive experience avail of course only 
up to a certain point in answering the question why flap extraction is sometimes followed by 
unfavorable results, just as the problem in general surgery, as to why wounds, that show 
every disposition to unite by first intention, sometimes suppurate, is capable of an only par- 
tial solution. Still we may attempt to approximate to it by carefully noting and comparing 
the different circumstances influencing the patients, the eyes, the operation and the after- 
treatment in cases resulting favorably and unfavorably. And although I reserve for a spe- 
cial volume the results of my own experience in this connection, embracing at present 1500 
cases, I am still disposed to take a few cases of flap -extraction to illustrate some clinical re- 
marks bearing on this subject." 


combination of cataract with sclerectasia posterior — should never be 
omitted, was also answered in the negative. In a word, we have 
before us a so-called cataracta simplex. 

I say intentionally so called ; for strictly speaking it may be said that all eyes, 
in which cataract is spontaneously developed, may be found to have undergone 
more or less change in other respects, particularly in the hyaloid membranes and 
vascular system : in fact, these changes may well come to be looked upon as the 
pathological point of departure of the cataract ; meanwhile, however, the very great 
differences in respect to recovery, which at present fill us with astonishment and 
make us almost lose confidence in ourselves— especially when we compare them 
with the results of traumatic affections of otherwise healthy eyes— these differences, 
I say, may be explained by a closer study of the nature of the anomalies which are 
at the bottom of the formation of the cataract. Such theorizing, however, car- 
ries us into an obscure future ; it suits our present purpose to limit cataracta sim- 
plex to those cases where we are unable to discover any affection of the deeper 
structures of the eye, and no break exists in the nervous apparatus. 

Shall this patient be operated on at present ? There is certainly 
no valid reason for delay ; in fact, we hold it prudent to do the ope- 
ration of flap-extraction on only one eye at a time,* and it is only in 
exceptional cases and under extraordinary circumstances that we 
depart from this rule. In one eye the cataract is ripe. Did the 
patient enjoy tolerable vision with the other eye, and could she gain 
her living, we might advise a postponement of the operation ; for 
three months, however, she has not been able to go about alone, which 
fact makes the recovery of sight a matter of prime necessity under 
any circumstances. 

Let us now come to an understanding with regard to the prognosis 
of a flap- extraction in tha present case. And first, as to the general 
state of the system. The patient, it is true, is only 64 years old, 
but prematurely marasmic. This is sufficiently shown in the deep 
wrinkles, the atrophy of the skin all over the body, particularly on 
the neck and backs of the hands, the scanty and thinly sown gray 

[* In view of the difference of opinion on this important point, which has prevailed and to 
some extent still exists in this country, the translator would call attention to the accompany- 
ing passage from the excellent work of Wccker, now in process of publication :— 

•' The elementary principles of prudence indicate sufficiently the impropriety of perform- 
ing the operation for cataract on more than one eye at a time. In the first place, the conse- 
quences of the first operation and the results which it furnishes are, for the surgeon, the 
source of valuable information with regard to the line of conduct he should pursue in the 
second. In the second place, no conscientious operator would consent to expose his patient 
to the risk of losing, at one cast, all hope of recovering sight, a thing which might happen 
after a double extraction, followed by accidents entirely independent of the operation itself, 
and determined by the imprudence of the patient or of the persons surrounding him."— 
Etudes Ophthalmohgiqites, tome ii. p. 255.] 


hair, the somewhat stooping form and a weight of 88 pounds to a 
height of 5 feet 3 inches. In my estimation, marasmus should exert 
a most unfavorable influence on the prognosis of flap-extraction, that 
which is premature more than that which legitimately belongs to the 
time of life.* But we find, moreover, in the eyes themselves circum- 
stances Which contribute to depress our hopes, namely, the deeply 
sunken position of the balls, the small corneal diameter, which we 
have just found to hardly measure 4f", and a tremulousness in the 
muscles when the eyes are turned far in or out. A sunken position 
of the balls has been particularly dwelt upon as an unfavorable cir- 
cumstance, in so far as it interferes with the mechanical execution of 
the operation. Viewed in this aspect, I do not attach much impor- 
tance to it, for when extraction is done downwards a moderate 
amount of practice enables us to overcome the difficulties in question. 
But an abnormally deep position of the eyes, depending, as it does 
in general marasmus, on the disappearance incidental to age of the 
fatty tissue of the orbit, is, it is somewhat probable, an unfavorable 
sign as regards recovery ; in fact, it is very probably so when, cou- 
pled with it, is the second sign to which we have referred, the senile 
dimiuution in diameter of the cornea. Where such a combination 
exists we are almost sure to have collapse of the cornea after the 
operation ; that peculiar form of collapse in which the cornea not 
only falls in, lies loose and in folds, but also exhibits a concentric 
shrivelling, the whole indicating that the corneal tissue is capable of 
but little resistance. Experience shows more and more that the 
loss of nutrition which is brought about by the flap-section is fraught 
with peculiar danger to such a cornea, and is followed not infre- 
quently by total or partial suppuration. The same thing happens in 
the case of these thin and but slightly elastic cornese, as in a plastic 
operation where the skin is thin, atrophic, and devoid of panniculus ; 
a loss of nutrition that, under more favorable circumstances, would 
be perfectly supportable, giving rise to fears of suppurative destruc- 
tion or entire necrosis, an unusual amount of contraction being ob- 
servable in the skin as soon as separated from its original insertion. 
Finally, the third sign, viz., the nystagmic trembling of the muscles 

* The opinion of some colleagues that extreme age does not exert a particularly unfavora- 
ble influence on extraction is most emphatically contradicted by my tables, which show- 
after the 65th, and particularly after the 70th year, a considerable falling off in the percent- 
a ge of recoveries. 


when made to exert their utmost contractile power, goes to show a se- 
nile atrophy of the muscular apparatus and to confirm our fears that 
the wound may not heal well. It is thus made evident that the danger of 
a diffuse (necrotic) as well as of a defined (flap) suppurative process is 
extraordinarily great in the present case. 

The tendency, too, to iritis is decidedly greater in marasmic eyes 
(increasing, as it does, in proportion to the age). The hardness of 
the cataract tends to render this more probable, greater violence being 
done as it passes through the pupil. Still, I should not say that the 
affair promised particularly ill in this respect; for one of the cata- 
racts is entirely ripe, from which we infer an entire and easy sepa- 
ration of it from the capsule, and have neither to apprehend difficulty 
or delay in the removal of the cortical masses, nor that any will re- 
main behind — a fertile cause of iritis. Moreover, atropine brings 
about a complete dilatation of the pupil, a small border of iris alone 
remaining, and it continues well dilated for four or five days, a thing 
by no means universal with old people, and which indicates relative- 
ly less tendency to iritis. In order not to be misunderstood, I should 
here add that I consider the iritis following extraction as capable of 
classification under two heads — transplanted and genuine. The trans- 
planted follows upon or becomes developed with the suppuration of 
the wound, the latter either leading to a cell-growth, on the posterior 
surface of the cornea, which pushes into the pupil, or else the suppu- 
ration seizes upon the portion of the iris in the immediate vicinity of 
the wound, and thence invades the remainder of the iris and the 
ciliary region. The genuine iritis, which seldom comes on before 
the third day, and generally makes its appearance between the fourth 
and tenth, has no direct effect on the healing of the wound, but when 
of early occurrence may influence it unfavorably, though indirectly. 
This form alone was, of course, that to which we had reference, the 
transplanted variety having its own exciting cause. 

Finally, it should be stated that the patient suffers from an old 
stoppage of the lachrymal passage and moderate epiphora, a circum- 
stance which is shown from experience to somewhat diminish the 
chances in favor of the healing of the wound. 

Taking all these circumstances into account, the general prognosis 
of flap-extraction must be here essentially modified. According to 
my reckoning, of a hundred cases of flap extraction 65 result favor- 
ably, by which I mean the gaining an acuteness of vision of at least 


J ; if more than 75 years of age, at least h In 15 of the remaining 
35 a favorable result is attained by a subsequent operation, consisting 
either m an operation for secondary cataract, or in an iridectomy with 
an operation for secondary cataract ■ of the 20 that now remain about 
a third get at least vision enough to go about alone (acuteness of 
vision -^ to 3V), a second third gain still less, and from 6 to 8 per 
cent, of all eyes operated on remain or become entirely blind; that 
is, deprived of all ability to distinguish objects (whether they have 
quantitative perception of light or no). This is the final exhibit, 
when I take into account all the cases of cataracta simplex* where 
an operation seems indicated. 

Under other circumstances much more flattering statistics could be shown ; my 
own, for instance, would have been twice as good if I had only included the ope- 
rations on the occupants of the private rooms of my infirmary, and omitted the 
poor patients, the majority of whom were operated on under very unfavorable 
circumstances. Far more favorable results, too, might be furnished by those 
practitioners who either employ another kind of operation in unfavorable cases, 
or decline such cases altogether, than by those who perform the operation of flap- 
extraction in all those cases in which an operation is not contra-indicated by the 
tenets of our science. Finally, I am convinced by my own experience that the 
recovery after extraction, like that after all surgical operations, is influenced by 
differences of climate. I therefore lay only a relative stress on the above statis- 
tics, and communicate them solely in order to furnish an average scale to the less 
experienced practitioner, who may wish to make a truthful statement to his pa- 
tient of the chances of the undertaking ; for the sake, moreover, of assigning to 
the present case its individual place on the general scale of prognosis. 

As may be readily seen, the prognosis of extraction may be infi- 
nitely better in a single case than in the .long run, and vice versa. 
Imagine a patient in the vicinity of fifty years of age, perfectly 
healthy, of an equable temperament, submissive, hopeful as regards 
his future, with a large cornea of 5£'", a cataract ripe for the last 
quarter or half year, and with soft cortical substance — the chance of 
success would here be exceedingly good, infinitely better than the 
given average. An opposite condition of things inclines the scale in 
the contrary direction, and thus is it in fact in the case before us. I 
should here hardly estimate the chances of immediate and entire 

* The more marked cases of myopia were formerly excluded from the list ; latterly, how- 
ever, have been reckoned in, provided no amblyopic complication could be discovered before 
the operation. This seemed allowable because, contrary to anticipations, experience has 
shown the healing process to be in no wise unfavorably affected by the staphyloma posticum 
(provided the vitreous is not considerably changed). 


success as more than even, while the chances of an ultimate recovery, 
to be obtained by a secondary operation, are as 2 to 1. 

Is, then, for this reason, another plan of operating to be selected ? 
The hardness of the cataract forbids the thought of discission, an 
operation, indeed, seldom advisable in advanced age ; nor are we 
likely to choose linear extraction, with or without iridectomy, an ope- 
ration which, in cataracts as consistent as the present, does too much 
violence, leaves cortical substance behind, and is followed by chronic 
iritis, which generally invades the ciliary region. Our sole choice, 
therefore, lies between flap-extraction and reclination. The chance, 
on the whole, after reclination is very unfavorable compared with 
that after flap-extraction. If the average success following the former 
is to be reckoned as at least 80 per cent., that belonging to the latter 
is at the outside 50 per cent. Still, a fair field for reclination might be 
found in those cases where the individual circumstances cause the 
chances of extraction to fall considerably below the average. It is? 
however, in this connection to be regretted that most of the physical 
objections which, in a given case, apply to flap-extraction, may be urged 
with equal or greater cogency against reclination. Thus it is, for 
example, with certain complications which have been actually brought 
forward as contra-indications to flap-extraction, for example chronic 
choroiditis with a fluid condition of the vitreous. Their existence, of 
course, interposes a serious obstacle in the way of extraction, but a 
still greater one in that of reclination. Supposing, then, an opera- 
tion to be advisable, they are not to be considered as contra-indica- 
tions to the former, but simply as unfavorably modifying the progno- 
sis. The same is true, though perhaps not so emphatically, of 
marasmic eyes like the present, unable as they are to long endure 
the irritation set up by the displaced lens, the tendency being to the 
development of chronic cyclitis or deep-seated inflammations, attend- 
ed by increased secretion and ending in excavation of the optic 
nerve, the whole contributing to establish a prognosis for reclination 
much below the average. In my opinion, reclination is to be regard- 
ed as an incontestably proper though exceptional procedure in those 
cases where the general state of the system renders the healing of 
the wound doubtful, and where the danger of choroiditis or of in- 
flammation with hypersecretion does not increase in the same ratio. 
After all, a too exclusive predilection should not be allowed to turn 
the scale in balancing chances. Signal as seems in the light of to- 


day to be the blunder of submitting to the insidious operation of 
inclination an eye which offers an average or even better prospect of 
success from extraction, there yet remains scope for the exercise of 
some choice or preference on the part of the operator in cases like 
the present, where extraction offers a decidedly diminished chance. 
And although in the case of our patient extraction seems on the 
whole more advisable than inclination, we should readily compre- 
hend and in no wise find fault with the course of any colleague who 
employed by preference the needle. 

Flap-extraction having once been determined on, we have to decide 
whether to precede it by an iridectomy, or perhaps combine the two 
operations. What advantage is to be gained by combining an iridec- 
tomy with a flap-extraction ? Does it ward off the danger of diffuse 
suppuration of the cornea, a process occurring as a general thing 
between twelve and twenty-four hours after the operation, and cha- 
racterized by profuse secretion, appearances of swelling and the 
rapid formation of a purulent infiltration encircling the entire cornea, 
and premonitory of necrosis of this structure ? Not in the least. We 
have seen this very thing occurring in the same manner and running 
the same course in cases of extraction where the precaution of mak- 
ing an artificial pupil had been adopted. Only in proportion as the 
presence of the coloboma renders the mechanical execution of the 
operation in itself more easy, can it be said that an indirect influ- 
ence has been exerted on the occurrence of the above process. 

Does the presence of the coloboma afford any protection against 
defined suppuration, the symptoms of which generally make their ap- 
pearance somewhat later (eighteen to thirty-six hours), are other- 
wise externally similar to those of diffuse suppuration, except that 
the secretion is less abundant, and after having been poured out for 
the first time somewhat diminishes, in which, however, the suppura- 
tive process confines itself to the vicinity of the wound or the cor- 
neal flap, and at the most exhibits a tendency to send a ring-shaped 
infiltration into the uncut portion of the cornea ? This query, too, 
must be answered in the negative. Since the time that I have com- 
bined iridectomy with extraction to meet various indications, I have 
not noticed any influence of the procedure (making again the same 
allowance as above for its effect on the act of the operation) on the 
occurrence of defined suppuration of the wound, but have, however — 
and this is a very important point — on its course. The principal 


danger of defined suppuration, always supposing it does not ulti- 
mately become diffuse, lies not so much in the destruction of the 
cornea, as in the iritis transplanted from the wound (see above). The 
masses of pus make their way into the anterior chamber, the iris 
becomes the seat of suppurative swelling, and this transplanted sup- 
purative iritis exhibits a peculiar tendency to invade the ciliary 
region, and thus lead to irrecoverable loss of sight from ciliary exu- 
dations and atrophy of the bulb. The existence of a coloboma of 
the iris does not, it is true, remove the possibility of such an inva- 
sion, but is undeniably efficacious in hindering its progress. The 
process attains a diminished height, union of the edge of the pupil 
with the capsular cavity takes place more quietly and frequently to 
a less extent, and purulent cyclitis fails to make its appearance in 
many cases, where, but for the coloboma, it might have been expected. 
Does the iridectomy afford any protection against general iritis, 
the development of which is in most cases owing to contusion of the 
iris during the operation, or to the leaving behind of cortical re- 
mains ? To a certain extent, we need not hesitate to answer this in 
the affirmative. The protection furnished is, of course, by no means 
absolute j genuine iritis, however, is less frequently observed where 
iridectomy has been done in advance, and when it does occur is, as 
a rule, less severe. It is plain that the amount of contusion inflicted 
during the operation is less when a coloboma of the iris exists oppo- 
site the apex of the flap. And, where the amount of contusion is 
the same, an iris in which a coloboma has been made exhibits a les- 
sened tendency to inflammation, and inflammation of it is less dan- 
gerous ; on all sides, therefore, are favorable circumstances which 
give us an a priori ground for foreseeing the result which experi- 
ence renders secure. It is, moreover, indubitable that iridectomy 
interposes a serious though not invincible obstacle in the way of a 
prolapse of the iris, and appreciably lessens the dangers of such a 

We have alluded in this connection only to the more common events that in- 
terfere with the healing process after extraction. There are others, more excep- 
tional, however, in their character. To these belongs a disease which is clearly 
to be distinguished from genuine iritis — iridophacitis (observed six times in 1200 
cases) — a state in which, while the inflammatory symptoms gradually increase, 
the whole capsular cavity becomes transformed — through hypertrophy of the in- 
tracapsular cells — into a bag of pus, while the iris at first plays but a subordi- 
nate part in the inflammation, and the ciliary region becomes only subsequently 


affected. In this category is, moreover, to be classed the affection to which I 
have given the name of phagedenic wound-pustule, and which may bring about a 
disastrous result as late as the third or even the fourth week ; its occurrence, 
however, being fortunately even less frequent (four cases observed out of 1500). 
These processes are not, be it incidentally remarked, particularly affected by iri- 
dectomy. It accidentally happened that the most of our scanty observations 
were made on eyes on which a preparatory iridectomy had been done. Direct 
purulent infiltration of the vitreous, a thing that may develope itself after a loss 
of this humor or intra-ocular hsemorrhage, should also be reckoned in, were we 
making a careful statement of the things that might take place after an extrac- 
tion, and not simply sketching their relation to iridectomy. 

On a general review of the foregoing, it appears that iridectomy 
offers no protection against the occurrence of diffuse and partial 
suppuration, while on the other hand it does, in the case of the latter, 
go to ensure a more favorable course of things, and to a certain ex- 
tent prevents the occurrence of iritis and prolapse of the iris. We 
may thence deduce the general principle that a portion of the dan- 
gers attendant on extraction are obviated by iridectomy, and that 
this operation is therefore to be employed where such dangers are 
imminent. As regards the particular indications, I stated several 
years ago (Archive of Ophthalmology, vol. ii., part 2, pp. 247-248, 
1854) that iridectomy should always be done when the performance 
of the operation was attended with any difficulty ; for instance, when, 
owing to the small size of the flap, to too small an opening in the 
capsule, or to too much adherence of the cortical substance, the lens 
did not slip easily out, but advanced with evident difficulty. Then I 
laid stress on iridectomy in cases where prolapse of the iris seemed 
probable, owing to unsatisfactory juxtaposition of the edges of the 
wound, to a tendency of the pupil to prolong itself in the direction 
of the wound. I do. not, moreover, fail to perform iridectomy where 
entirely hard cataract exists in connection with a small pupil, difficult 
of dilatation ; where cortical masses not yet completely ripe are 
with difficulty removed or have to be left behind, or where the former 
is true of a case of ripe cataract owing to the consistency and adhe- 
rence of the cortical masses. Iridectomy, too, is to be advised in 
any case where the chance of a good union of the wound is small, 
because it may possibly contribute to a favorable result in the event 
of defined suppuration. 

Is iridectomy always to be combined with extraction? Were the dangers of 
the operation actually diminished thereby, and were the procedure itself unac- 
companied by any drawbacks, it would seem as though the question must be an- 


swered in the affirmative. Let candor, however, be scrupulously observed. The 
thing is by no means without its drawbacks. In the case of very restless patients 
its simultaneous performance meets with some obstacles and is attended with 
some anxiety ; on neither of which points, however, am I inclined to lay as much 
stress as does my good friend Mooren, who has recently in a very meritorious 
manner drawn public attention to the combined procedure. An iridectomy done 
some time beforehand has the one decided disadvantage of subjecting the patients 
to a double operation, prolonging their stay in the hospital, and of sometimes, 
through delay, destroying their moral courage ; indeed, if the principle of a long 
interval be defended, it is often incompatible with external circumstances. More 
especially, however, is the fact undeniable that the vision of patients having a 
coloboma downwards and no accommodation, labors under some disadvantages — 
it not being necessary to regard cosmetic considerations with old people — when 
contrasted with cases where the pupil is central. These disadvantages apply less 
to the amount than to the distinctness of vision, and obtain particularly in in- 
stances where little irregularities of curvature or cloudy opacities of the cornea 
result in the vicinity of the wound after extraction, as not infrequently happens. 
These disadvantages are, to be sure, of minor consequence ; inasmuch, however, 
as iridectomy directly benefits only the minority of operative cases, and it is ex- 
ceedingly probable that its performance under favorable circumstances is super- 
fluous, I am unable, after weighing the pros and cons, to pronounce in favor of its 
general adoption in cases of extraction. It gives me pleasure, however, to see it 
done by others,* because an evident advantage accrues to science from its gene- 
ral application and a conscientious determination of results. 

In the case of our patient, iridectomy is clearly indicated on the 
ground of probable suppuration of the flap. 

It remains to decide whether iridectomy shall be done at the same 
time with the extraction, or shall precede it. The latter is, in my 
opinion, more judicious. Where the eye is unsteady its simultane- 
ous performance is attended with certain practical difficulties or at 
least annoyances ; also, with the disadvantage of a subsequent small 
haemorrhage into the anterior chamber, which although in itself insig- 
nificant, may embarrass the third and fourth steps of a modified linear 

* The proposition to always combine iridectomy with extraction was made some time 
ago, as may be seen by referring to the following passage from my writings (loc. tit.) pub- 
lished nine years ago : — " Were any one to conceive the idea of making a pupil upwards a 
few weeks before extracting, as was in fact proposed to me by several, the only objection I 
should have to offer would be that in the infinitely greater number of cases the thing is un- 
necessary, and would be hardly compatible with the limited sojourn of the patients. On the 
other hand, such a procedure might be defensible on the ground of safety and as a prophy- 
lactic." With people who have only one eye, I have invariably practised this procedure for 
several years, for although, where other things are favorable, the danger of suppuration or 
iritis is not imminent, yet it must be taken into account in every extraction, and the lessened 
probability of it which is brought about by an iridectomy seems to me to outweigh the ob- 
jections already referred to, especially when we consider the disastrous consequence of a 
want of success. 


extraction, when iridectomy has been done as second act ; moreover, 
while the recent formation of a coloboma certainly diminishes the ten- 
dency to a general iritis, the freshly cut edges of the coloboma do still 
incline to inflammation, resulting in union with the capsule, when irri- 
tated by the passage of the lens. These objections disappear when 
we find the coloboma ready made ; the operation has then only its 
three usual steps, and is more quickly completed. I think that too 
short an interval should not be allowed to elapse between the iridec- 
tomy and the extraction. It is not advisable to do the operation within 
less than four, if possible six weeks of the other. Although the 
more evident signs of a tendency to irritability, consequent on iri- 
dectomy, may have disappeared, yet their traces may be observed in 
the redness of the parts met with after sleep, or in the minute infil- 
tration in the neighboring portion of the cornea, revealed by oblique 
illumination j experience, moreover, shows that a too rapid succes- 
sion of operations exerts a cumulative effect on circumstances dis- 
posing to inflammation, which, where the disposition to recovery is 
not a decided one, may give an impetus in the wrong direction. In 
short, if circumstances do not permit a longer interval than four 
weeks, I do the whole thing at one sitting, preferring this course, not- 
withstanding its disadvantages, to a double operation. 

The poor patient whose case is in question is unable, owing to ex- 
ternal circumstances, to lengthen her stay beyond what is absolutely 
necessary, still less to come back again. We have efther, then, to do 
the iridectomy a week or ten days in advance, in contravention of 
the principle above established, or perform it simultaneously. 

When, during the operation, unforeseen circumstances render ne- 
cessary the performance of iridectomy, it forms of course the fourth 
step. Where the patient is restless, it is certainly attended with 
difficulty. Not infrequently too small a piece of iris is excised, the 
operator fearing to draw it too far forward, or dreading that an un- 
expected movement of the eye may give rise to dialysis or a loss of 
vitreous. Doing the operation, however, as the second step, immedi- 
ately after the completion of the corneal section, involves much less 
difficulty, and is of course to be advised in all cases where, as in the 
present instance, the performance of iridectomy had been previously 
determined on. 


January 5th. — Before proceeding to operate on the case of cataract 
recently referred to, I have the following remarks to make. 

All so-called preparatory treatment is not only superfluous but mis- 
chievous, unless, indeed, there are special circumstances in the indi- 
vidual case requiring attention. The healing process, after extrac- 
tion, goes on most favorably when the person operated on is in a 
high state of health, and is, so to speak, morally and physically well 
balanced. Even an active cathartic is to be shunned, the excitability 
of the patient being thereby increased. It is sufficient to induce a 
gentle evacuation by the use of castor oil, or some other mild laxa- 
tive, the day before the operation. If we have a chance of previ- 
ously watching the patient, it would be well to test the effect of a 
dose of morphine at least two days before the operation, in order to 
ascertain how the individual is affected by a drug we are so likely to 
subsequently employ, and which acts so differently in different cases. 

A very important factor is the frame of mind of the patient, which 
may be such as to require encouragement. With many it is best to 
make no previous allusion to the operation. The course to be pur- 
sued must be left to the tact of the surgeon, who must lose no time 
in taking into account the imaginative tendencies of the patient. Ex- 
perience shows that the patients who are free from care and full of 
hope do much better than those of excitable temperament and op- 
pressed with anxious forebodings. During the operation, too, a word 
from the operator is, under many circumstances, of as much conse- 
quence as his manipulations. Avoid scolding or threatening, even 
when patients misbehave themselves, for such a course seldom fails to 
depress their spirits and paralyze their self-control. Jocular allu- 
sions, calculated to abstract their attention from the critical moment 
they are passing through, often have a good effect. It is a well- 
known rule not to let the patients wait long for the operation, but to 
perform it as soon as possible after it has once been decided on. 
Bad weather or indifferent light should not be allowed to weigh as 
much with us as depression of spirits on the part of the patient. 

Is atropine to be instilled before the operation ? Objections have 
been raised to this, particularly by English surgeons. It has been 
argued that the iris, being drawn back by the mydriatic, becomes 
thicker, and hence more liable to be injured by the cataract knife. 
It has been even argued that no real object is attained, inasmuch as 
the pupil contracts again after the evacuation of the aqueous humor ; 


and, finally, a fear has been expressed that the peripheric retraction 
of the iris may diminish the protection afforded the vitreous humor, 
and thus favor its escape. None of these objections appear to me 
well grounded. Even were the iris to increase in thickness as the 
pupil widened, it would be a matter of entire indifference ; for if we 
take a case where extraction has been properly performed and exa- 
mine the inner wound, it will be found that its arc nearly coincides 
with the edge of the enlarged pupil, or that its diameter barely ex- 
ceeds that of the latter. It will therefore be found, in cases where 
mydriasis is complete, that the iris is either outside of the inner cut, 
or else that only a narrow border of pupil falls within it, and that 
this cannot possibly be so thick as to come in contact with the point 
of the knife, which is either close to the inner face of the cornea, or 
has attained to a corresponding point on the other side. It is true 
that the pupil contracts again after the escape of the aqueous. 
Leaving, however, out of sight the fact that the contraction itself is 
less than if no atropine has been employed, we should remember that 
our object is not so much to enlarge a firmly closed pupil — the influ- 
ence of which in preventing a facile exit of (he lens was formerly 
unduly feared — as to render more easy the completion of the section, 
during which, of course, the mydriasis persists. Finally, the objec- 
tion that the use of atropine increases the chances of a loss of the 
vitreous is neither theoretically plausible nor confirmed by experi- 
ence. I am accordingly disposed not only to dismiss the objections 
against, but to positively approve the use of atropine the evening be- 
fore the operation. It is unquestionable that the completion of the 
section is thereby facilitated, especially when the anterior chamber is 
narrow, for the iris is thus entirely or nearly withdrawn from the 
region of the inner cut. It moreover strikes me as of importance 
that after the re-secretion of the aqueous humor the mydriasis in 
part returns, a fact that may be demonstrated by instilling atropine 
into the eye of an animal, then doing paracentesis and awaiting the 
refilling of the anterior chamber. This secondary mydriasis has 
some influence in averting a tendency to inflammation on the part of 
the iris. Finally, the paralysis of the ciliary muscle, persisting as it 
does after paracentesis, must be productive of good. 

The operation itself has already been alluded to. We have yet 
to decide on the direction of the section. This paves the way for the 
general discussion as to whether extraction up or down offers the 


more advantages. Having once adopted the compressive bandage, 
the use of which brings with it the principal advantages of the upper 
section, I became more and more a partizan of extraction down- 
wards, after having for six years practised exclusively the other 
method. My experience shows that an operation upwards and one 
downwards, each done according to rule, offer practically equal 
chances of success. Although, on the one hand, the average length 
of after-treatment of extraction upwards is three days less (twenty- 
one to twenty-four days' stay in the hospital), the percentage of pro- 
lapse of the iris, of iritis and of suppuration is the same j while, on 
the other hand, it must be conceded that partial suppuration does less 
damage in a case of lower than of upper section, the tendency to 
gravitate downwards being productive of evil results. It must fur- 
ther be alleged in support of the lower section that its employment 
renders it possible to do a greater number of operations strictly ac- 
cording to rule, the surgeon being less dependent on the docility of 
the patient, and even on that of the assistant. It is here in his 
power to prevent the flap from coming into rude contact with, or be- 
ing everted by the lief, and to get rid of cortical substance without 
the introduction of instruments, <fcc, even when the patient has but 
little control over the movements of his eye. It is true that, with 
sufficient practice, the upper section gives very good results, even in 
cases where the eyes are deep seated, the patients unruly, &c. ; still, 
the greater length of the operation and the danger of reversing the 
flap against the upper lid are disadvantages which, however skilfully 
they may be met, increase the amount of manipulation, interfere with 
the mechanical execution of the operation, and in a doubtful case 
may incline the scale in the wrong direction. 

As is usually the case when the merits of different operations are under discus- 
sion, we have in the present case a variety of reasons for and against, the most of 
which experience has shown to be visionary. For instance, it has been alleged 
that vitreous was, by the law of gravity, more likely to be lost in extracting 
downwards. The reverse would be more correct. Vitreous escapes when the 
zonula or hyaloid are ruptured, a thing the less likely to happen in proportion as the 
exit of the lens and cortical substance is facilitated, which indubitably is true in 
the case of the lower section. It has been, moreover, asserted that corneal opaci- 
ties, when they result, are productive of more disturbance] in the case of the 
lower than of the upper section. Corneal opacities that amount to anything, 
however, only result from an exceptional condition of things, from prolapse of 
the iris or partial suppuration. The former would be accompanied by a disloca- 
tion of the pupil, which, in the general run of cases, had better take place above 


than below; while, in the latter, the pupil is either closed or contracted, and an iri- 
dectomy is indicated at any rate. It is also objected to the lower section that, if the 
edges of the wound are not in exact apposition, the border of the lower lid may 
get in the way; such a malposition, however, seldom occurs, and would not be 
allowed to remain. Whichever method were employed, a portion of the iris 
would have to be excised, and perhaps some vitreous evacuated, both of which 
things are more readily done in the case of the lower than of the upper section. 
"Where the operation downwards has been done according to rule, the flap lies in 
such exact apposition that the lower lid causes no derangement of the parts, 
even when the gaze is suddenly directed downwards. Since commencing the syste- 
matic employment of the compressive bandage I do not, even where the eyes are 
unnaturally prominent, hesitate jto extract downwards. I do not, however, give 
myself out as an opponent of extraction upwards. By so doing I should dispar- 
age the excellent results which many operators have thus obtained, and even the 
results of my own previous experience. I have already admitted that the ave- 
rage length of after-treatment is less in extraction upwards, owing to the fact 
that in a case of lower section, where no bandage has been used, the vicinity of 
the wound is more apt to be irritated by the action of the lids than when the cut 
is above and thus protected. I merely wished to draw attention to the fact that 
the much-vaunted superiority of the upper section is in many respects visionary, 
and that its real advantage, which consists in the uniform protection and pressure 
afforded by the upper lid to the wound during its first union, has been fully com- 
pensated by the introduction of the compressive bandage, and can no longer be used 
as an argument against the other method, the execution of which is more rapid, 
and in which we are less dependent on the patient. And if the results are, as I 
•do not dispute, on the whole equally good, the preference must be given to extrac- 
tion downwards on account of the greater facility with which it is performed. At 
all events, I advise the expert as well as the neophyte, in the case of a restless 
patient, to extract downwards. 

In our own case we have, moreover, a special reason for choosing 
the lower section, viz., the iridectomy we are to interpolate as the 
second step. With the upper section the excision of a piece of iris, 
corresponding with the apex of the cut, is a very ticklish thing, un- 
less we are aided by entire tranquillity on the part of the patient. 
Otherwise the excision must be lateral, and we gain only a partial 

We shall, in accordance with our usual practice, operate on this patient 
in bed. Although this position is not entirely convenient for the opera- 
tor, the patient enjoys the advantage of the greatest possible amount of 
muscular relaxation, and has afterwards to make no change. Surgeons 
who operate on their patients sitting are compelled, when anything 
out of the way occurs, to get them to bed during the operation, inas- 
much as in certain contingencies— such as escape of the vitreous— 
the horizontal position is indispensable. As we are to deal with the 


right eye, the operator must sit behind the head of the bed, unless 
he happens by some freak of nature to be ambidexter, or else during 
his medical education was influenced by a now exploded ophthalmic 
hobby and worked up a partial ambidexterity, for worked up it must 
be. The choice is free to all ; still, being sworn foes to all surgical 
coquetry, we would remind those who plume themselves on am- 
bidexterity that the creation of practical difficulties, when such might 
with entire propriety be avoided, is less a merit than an indiscre- 
tion. It is not likely that any surgeon would acquire a title to dex- 
terity because he amputated one leg with the right hand and the 
other with the left, instead of so varying his position as to do both 
with the right hand. The same holds with regard to ophthalmic 
operations, provided the principle of operating on the patient in a 
recumbent position be once adopted. 

January 5th, P.M. — There is but little to say with regard to the 
operation which has just been performed. The measurement of the 
cornea showing its diameter to be but small, the cataract knife had 
to be introduced close to the scleral edge. Under the circumstances 
it was only thus possible to form a cut of sufficient size j in cases, 
however, where the cornea is larger it is practicable to make both 
puncture and counter-puncture at the distance of a millimetre from 
the scleral edge. When the points of entrance and emergence are 
taken close to the scleral edge and the cut rounded off to correspond, 
we are apt, as in the present case, to get a small flap of conjunctiva, 
to the existence of which we are neither disposed to attribute un- 
pleasant consequences nor attach a particularly favorable significance. 
Both views have, however, been held, the last, as is well known, hav- 
ing of late been strongly insisted on by an eminent practitioner, who 
regards the conjunctival flap as a strong safeguard against suppura- 
tion of the wound, and insists on its regular formation. When the 
conjunctiva is cut we do not regard it advisable to form a long and 
narrow flap, because that is apt to bleed and may prevent apposition 
of parts. It is better to turn the knife at a right angle to its previ- 
ous position and cut directly out. 

Just before completing the flap, the fixation forceps, the use of 
which in cases of flap-extraction may be conscientiously recommend- 
ed, were laid aside, and the upper lid suffered to drop completely 
down. Manifest advantages attend the latter manoeuvre, which is, of 
course, only practicable with the lower section. If the cut has approach- 


ed within about 1'" of its completion, its form is already a settled 
thing and no particular results would accrue from turning the knife 
more or less forwards. No further reason, therefore, exists for re- 
quiring as much of a palpebral aperture as is usually sought. The 
assistant should let go of the lid. The operator, who has laid down 
the fixation forceps and therefore has his other hand at his disposal, 
should use it for the purpose of gentle traction downwards on the 
cheek, in order to complete the cut while withdrawing the knife, 
without wounding the edge of the lid, and yet under the same cir- 
cumstances as if both were closed. The palpebral pressure is thus, 
at this critical moment, reduced to a minimum, and protrusion of the 
iris, sudden loss of the aqueous humor, or even escape of the vitre- 
ous, are less liable to occur with unruly patients. 

Collapse of the cornea, which the deep-set position of the eyes and 
the diameter of the cornea had led us to predict, took place after the 
first step (of the operation). It became strongly marked after th,e 
completion of the other three steps, concerning the execution of 
which I have nothing to add. The cornea finally nestled down in 
plaits, the edges of the wound, however, being in entirely good ap- 
position, as was tested by restoring with the finger some degree of 
tension to the ball. 

Immediately after the operation the compressive bandage, in com- 
mon use at my infirmary, was applied. The orbital hollow is first 
evenly packed with charpie, which has been picked over and put 
together in the form of small tufts, the whole being secured by a 
single turn of a snug-fitting flannel bandage passing over one eye. 
This is held in place by another single turn around the forehead, the 
first half of which comes before, the other half after the turn passing 
over the eye. The middle portion of the bandage passing over the 
eye is knit of cotton and not of flannel. Special stress is to be laid 
on the proper management of this bandage* in cases of collapse of 
the cornea. Tolerably firm pressure must be made during the first 

* I am preparing for the Archive an article on the subject of this bandage. [This has 
already appeared. See Archiv fur Ophthalmologic, Bd. ix. Abth. 2, S. 111.— Translator.] I 
would only here observe that to Sichel particularly, of modern ophthalmologists, is due the 
credit of the introduction into practice of the compressive bandage after extraction (since 
1842, see Gaz. des Hopit., 1853, No. 54),and that I was incited by the personal solicitation of 
Sichel to devote time to the study of this important subject. A letter of mine on the subject 
of the compressive and constrictive bandages may be found in the " Manual of General 
Ophthalmology," by Seitz and Zehender, p. 425 et seq., Erlangen, 1861. 


few hours, and then gradually relaxed in order not to hinder the 
escape of liquid secretions. 

January 6th, A.M. — Fifteen hours have passed since the operation 
without any complaint. Even the pain about the cut, which succeeds 
the operation, was totally absent. Is this to be construed as influ- 
encing for the better our unfavorable prognosis ? Not in the least. 
In marasmic eyes we not infrequently meet with a similar amount of 
sluggishness, lasting twelve, sixteen or eighteen hours, and then yield- 
ing to symptoms of diffuse or circumscribed suppuration. In look- 
ing through my records for the after-history of extraction done on 
marasmic eyes, I find that where there is absolute insensibility the 
prognosis is less satisfactory than in cases where a few hours after 
the operation a certain amount of pain developes itself in the wound, 
accompanied by slight swelling of the lid, reaching its height in from 
four to six hours and then disappearing.* 

6th, P.M. — The apprehensions expressed this morning have since 
unfortunately become realized. Shortly after the morning visit, about 
sixteen hours after the operation, the patient experienced a sensation 
in the eye, at first uncomfortable and then painful, and noticed an in- 
creased flow of tears. The bandage was removed eighteen hours 
after the operation. The nethermost layers of charpie were well 
soaked with a clear fluid. Since then both the swelling and the se- 
cretion have steadily increased. We now find, on opening the 
bandage, the lid already considerably tumefied, the folds broader, 
the deep hollow between the edge of the orbit and the bulb sensibly 
filled out in comparison with the other side, the whole superficies of 
the lid increased in volume. The furrow just above the internal pal- 
pebral ligament shows the characteristic swelling, oedematous and 
with. a dash of redness. The flow of tears not only did not diminish 
dtfring the morning, but has now become more and more mixed with 
a muco-purulent secretion. Although the bandage has been on only 
four hours, the whole lower layer of charpie is now soaked with pus. 
On removing the whole of the bandage several drops of a yellow 
secretion were observed to adhere to the edges of the lids. There 

* This applies, of course, to marasmic eyes alone. In other cases, where the operation 
has gone off in the usual manner, an entire absence of subsequent pain from the very first 
is highly favorable ; although it is an acknowledged fact that pain occurring within eight 
hours of the operation need cause much less anxiety and yields much more readily to treat- 
ment than when it comes on between twelve and thirty hours afterwards. 


is, to be sure, somewhat less pain, a circumstance which in no wise di- 
minishes our apprehensions, inasmuch as an abatement of the pain is 
often noticed as the suppuration becomes developed. 

To what shall we attribute the symptoms ? Without doubt to a 
suppurative process of the cornea. Whether diffuse or circumscrib- 
ed cannot be decided till the lids are opened. A simple prolapse of 
the iris is out of the question. It might, to be sure, cause a moder- 
ate swelling of the lid and an increased flow of tears; the proof of 
its existence would be, however, the fact that the tears remained 
clear, and, even when persistent, were very seldom mixed with mass- 
es of mucus j the occurrence, too, of a prolapse of the iris after an 
iridectomy and a properly practiced incision, is very rare. It con- 
sists, too, in the outset, of a slight involvement of the iris, which, in 
the course of time, gradually becomes more prominent and gives rise 
to symptoms. Still less can the present case be one of genuine iri- 
tis. Leaving out of sight the fact that this need hardly be appre- 
hended in a case where the cataract was easily and entirely removed 
and iridectomy had been done, its existence would be indicated by 
neither the period, the symptoms, or especially the abundant secre- 

Can there, under existing circumstances, be any harm in opening the 
lids ? Although strongly disposed to postpone opening the lids till 
the fourth or fifth day in a case where all has gone along quietly, 
because a different course would be certainly unnecessary and possi- 
bly prejudicial, I see no objection, where things are going wrong, to 
gain a knowledge of the facts by a careful examination of the eye. 
Granting that we have here a case of general suppuration, we should 
then relinquish all hope and adapt our treatment to the general condition 
of the patient, studying her comfort the while. If, on the contrary, the 
case be one of circumscribed suppuration of the wound, preventing 
its closing, some hope would still remain, and we should have to be 
guided by a careful study of the healing tendencies. 

On proceeding, therefore, to open the eyes, several drops of a fluid 
composed of tears mixed with pus escaped from the conjunctival sac. 
The conjunctiva bulbi is tolerably reddened and pretty strongly che- 
motic. The entire corneal wound has become infiltrated with opaque, 
yellow matter to the extent of nearly V" and evidently throughout its en- 
tire thickness. The whole corneal flap moreover has a yellowish, sodden 
appearance. Through its upper third alone is the iris visible and the 


reestablishment of the anterior chamber evident. The corneal wound 
does not actually gape ; a study, however, of this stage in similar 
cases leads us to infer that the cut edges are not in contact through- 
out their entire thickness. The patient has satisfactory quantitative 
perception of light. 

How are we to regard this process ? From which tissue does the 
suppuration proceed ? There may those be still found who regard 
the iris as the source of the affection. But my anatomical and cli- 
nical studies have brought me to an opposite conclusion. When 
more extensive and spontaneous purulent infiltrations of the cornea 
show a tendency to extend to the epithelial layer of the membrane 
of Descemetand thence to the iris, much more would this tendency to 
diffusion be present in the case of a penetrating wound and violent 
suppuration. There is nothing surprising, then, in the suppuration of 
the wound being closely followed by turbidity of the aqueous and 
secondary iritis, the latter of which more readily attracts attention 
than the original affection, where cicatrization has already commenc- 
ed. Nor has the supposition that the visible symptoms proceed from 
a suppurative cyclitis or choroiditis, any clinical foundation. It is 
true that such results may follow extraction in rare and exceptional 
cases. Loss of vitreous, for example, may be immediately succeed- 
ed by a purulent infiltration of the deeper structures j in an ordinary 
case of suppuration, however, like the present, the deeper membranes 
become involved either by an extension of the suppurative affection 
of the cornea in the shape of a diffused purulent choroiditis or pan- 
ophthalmitis, or else the results of the secondary iritis develope them- 
selves insidiously, the products of inflammation on the posterior face 
of the iris attaining a complete union with the capsular cavity, and 
the whole resulting in a chronic cyclitis and a consequent atrophy of 
the bulb. A trial of the amount of perception of light enables us 
in each case to form an opinion. Even in cases of diffuse suppura- 
tion of the cornea we find, during the stage of the so-called periphe- 
ric abscess, both perception of light and field of vision normal, so 
long as no signs of deep-seated suppuration, such as rigidity and 
protrusion of the bulb, are present. This could not possibly be so, 
were the purulent affection of the cornea but an evidence of suppu- 
rative choroiditis. An anatomical investigation proves decisive, and 
this we once had an opportunity of making in an entirely typical 
case of suppuration of the cornea (peripheric abscess, coming on 


thirty-six hours after extraction, and described at length by Dr. 
Schweigger). The deeper structures were here found entirely 

Is the corneal suppuration to be regarded in the case of our patient 
as already diffuse (i. e., past aid) or circumscribed. Although the 
transparency of the greater part of the cornea has become impaired; 
yet it is only within the narrow streak following the edge of the 
wound that the infiltration has taken on the character of destructive 
suppuration. The remaining semi-transparent infiltration is at pre- 
sent to be considered as a swelling of the parenchyma, capable of 
retrogression. Moreover, a careful examination of the upper half of 
the cornea reveals the entire absence of that ominous circular infiltra- 
tion of pus, which, when it entirely surrounds the cornea, is a certain 
presage of necrosis and slough, and the proper pathognomonic mark 
of diffuse corneal suppuration. If, however, the case at the present 
time be one of circumscribed suppuration, or suppuration of the 
wound, it is highly probable that it will take on the diffuse form. 
Hardly twenty-eight hours have elapsed since the operation, the 
symptoms have been continually on the increase, the morbid process 
has its seat in a part which was known in advance as offering a poor 
field for action and inclined to suppurative processes ; every circum- 
stance is therefore unfavorable. Should diffuse suppuration not 
occur, hopes may yet be entertained ; the processes thus set up, how- 
ever, go to endanger the ultimate result, although here the existence 
of the coloboma is much in our favor. 

What can we do that will tend to limit the suppuration ? Shall 
ice-cold applications be made ? While they are of doubtful utility 
in a prophylactic point of view after an operation, they are to be 
decidedly condemned when suppuration has once commenced. This 
is eminently true of marasmic eyes. The application of cold does 
but accelerate the advance of the process most to be feared. 

Nor can I, under existing circumstances, recommend the applica- 
tion of leeches in the vicinity of the eye. Just in proportion as 
their use is beneficial in cases where the wound has healed, but 
where symptoms of irritation appear along its course or iritis comes 
on, so is their employment attended by danger during the early part 
of the healing process. Antiphlogistic treatment under such circum- 
stances owes its continued employment to the erroneous idea that 
whatever happens after an operation depends necessarily on an undue 


amount of inflammation. "When a marasmic patient has a wound 
that threatens to suppurate, no surgeon would think of applying 
leeches in its vicinity. And does not the same principle hold good 
of a part the already 'feeble nutrition of which has been impaired by 
an extensive incision ? The afflux of blood, induced by the suction 
of the leeches, naturally causes a more abundant inundation of the 
infiltrated parts, and the affair terminates unfavorably before the 
occurrence of the period of remission, from which good might other- 
wise be derived. It was sad experience, however, and not the theo- 
retical considerations which more tardily matured, that has led me 
to abstain from the application of leeches in the vicinity of the eye 
the first three days after an extraction. 

Shall venesection be performed ? I admit that this method is free 
from the disadvantages pertaining to leeches, that time is thus often 
gained when 'the symptoms are threatening, and the affection thus 
carried forward into a more propitious phase. But with maras- 
mic individuals it might have a deleterious effect upon the general 
health, while the chances of its furthering the healing process are more 
than problematical. Finally, when it is employed, it should be at 
the inception of the symptoms and not after suppuration has declared 

What remains to be done if thus much be rejected ? For a con- 
siderable time I have been in the habit of employing the so-called 
constrictive bandage in cases of circumscribed suppuration, and alter- 
nating it with warm aromatic applications when treating marasmic 
individuals. The former of these applications I cannot praise too 
highly. I have, within the last four months, seen its use followed by 
remarkable results in three cases which were running an anoma- 
lous course, and where some of the symptoms were more developed 
than in the present case.* In applying the constrictive bandage the 
orbit is packed in almost the same manner, only somewhat more 
plentifully, as when the compressive is used ; the whole being firmly 
secured by a flannel roller passed three times over the eye in ques- 
tion.f One shrinks at first from placing such a bandage on an eye 

* In one of these cases the commencement of a peripheric abscess existed, two thirds of 
the corneal edge remaining, it is true, free ; in spite of which the eye was saved, and hopes 
are entertained from a future iridectomy. 

f I shall take advantage of some proper opportunity to advert to some points connected 
with this bandage ; suffice it here to say that it has an entirely different effect from the pres- 
sure bandage, inasmuch as it not only actually supports the eye, but firmly presses the flap. 


where the lid is swollen and an active suppuration going on ; experi- 
ence shows, however, that when the proper indications are met, the 
patients find the application comfortable, and that swelling and sup- 
puration diminish to an extent that, under such desperate circum- 
stances, could have been expected with no other method. Such 
a bandage is ordered for this patient, with directions to have it 
changed every three hours, subsequently at longer intervals, in case 
the suppuration shows the desired diminution. Between the applica- 
tions of the bandage, camomile fomentations at a temperature of 95° 
are to be used on the lids, it being expected that 'they will contribute 
to the termination of the suppurative process. The diet is not to be 
lowered; the patient, on the contrary, is to be plied with bouillon 
and to drink milk. 

January "Jth. — During the last eighteen hours the bandage has been 
applied three times. The female attendant states that the first time 
it was removed there was a decided, and the second a notable dimi- 
nution in both the swelling and discharge. On removing it now 
only the under surface of the lowest layer of charpie is found per- 
meated by a purulent discharge, which is certainly infinitely less 
abundant than yesterday. The secretion begins to dry along the 
palpebral aperture, a fact which also denotes a diminution in quan- 
tity. The lid is still swollen, though unmistakably less, its folds are 
becoming less broad, more prominent, while here and there is seen a 
tendency to wrinkle. On opening the eye, as much improvement is 
seen as could have been expected in so short a time. The purulent 
infiltration at the lower part of the wound is beginning in some 
places to come away in the shape of a muco-purulent coating. The 
remaining corneal opacity extends as high up as yesterday; has 
changed its color, however, from yellowish to gray. Incisions are 
made in what chemosis exists ; the constrictive bandage is directed 
to be left on from six to eight hours, and camomile fomentations to 
be used but half an hour at a time- in the interval. 

January 9th. — During the last two days improvement has been 
more and more decided. The bandage was finally left on twelve 
hours together, and on its removal the lower layer of charpie was 
found dry, and the bit of linen covering the lids was all that the se- 
cretion caused to adhere ; this was, moreover, dry. The swelling of 
the lids had ceased, and the chemosis disappeared. By the aid of 
the forceps a species of muco-purulent slough could be picked from 


the wound ; and its removal brought into view the purulent infiltration 
of the edge of the wound, still in existence, but tending to consolida- 
tion. The infiltration of the flap had hardly a tinge of yellow in its 
appearance, but looked a good, healthy gray. Through its upper 
and already transparent edge could be seen the border of the dis- 
colored pupil (iritis propagata). The constrictive bandage was 
ordered to be continued and atropine to be instilled ; the warm fo- 
mentations were omitted. 

January 20th. — The progress of the case has been as favorable as 
could possibly have been anticipated. The purulent infiltration in 
the vicinity of the wound has become more and more consolidated, 
and will leave a cicatrix about }"' in breadth. A tissue in process 
of organization may be seen to extend from the wound to the pupil, 
indicating the course of the previous suppuration. The effect of 
the atropine may be seen in an enlargement of the pupil upwards; 
which is but very lightly filled with recently developed material, and 
allows the patient to count fingers held close to her. Although the 
artificial pupil is entirely filled and contracted, it must be allowed 
that its existence has materially contributed to the relatively favora- 
ble course of the transplanted iritis. Without it we should probably 
have had a suppurative and total fusion between the edge of the pu- 
pil and the capsular cavity, an accumulation of exudation on the 
posterior wall and cyclitis at a time when any fresh operative inter- 
ference was not to be lightly undertaken. In contrast with this we 
have the iris in an entirely normal plane, nowhere bellying forward, 
but slightly disorganized, free from large vessels — in short, the cili- 
ary region evidently uninvolved. 

That the eye did not fall a prey to diffuse suppuration, nay more, 
that a favorable terrain has been gained for a subsequent iridectomy, 
we are indubitably to ascribe to the use of the constrictive bandage, 
kept up for five days after the date of the last record. In this the- 
rapeutical conclusion I shall be confirmed by every colleague whose 
own experience has enabled him to gain an insight into such incidents 
as have been described, occurring so soon after the operation of ex- 
traction. Had it been possible for me to have seen the patient on 
the 6th, about eight hours before the evening visit, and thus previous* 
to the more abundant suppuration, and at that time to have ordered 
the constrictive bandage, it is probable that the use of this, under 
more favorable circumstances, would have produced more brilliant 


P. 17, 19th line from top, for intercranial read intracranial. 

P. 21, 17th line from bottom, for " that an affection of the fasciculus lateralis " 
and remainder of sentence, read " that an affection on the one side of the fasciculus 
lateralis, on the other of the fasciculus cruciatus alone, and not of the contiguous 
fibres, should be in question." 

P. 24, 9th line from top, for altered demeanor read a sense of confusion. 

P. 28, 1st line, for employee read employe.